We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Fire Island

Free Newsletter

Interested in Fire Island?

We'll send you updates with the latest deals, reviews and articles for Fire Island each week.

Fire Island | Fire Island Hotels | Fire Island Hotels by Type | Fire Island Attractions | Fire Island Restaurants | Fire Island Restaurants by Type | Fire Island Dish Pages | Fire Island Restaurants by Dining Options | Vacation Rentals | Flights | TripAdvisor pages

Up one level: Long Island

Fire Island Restaurants

Restaurants in Cherry Grove Restaurants in Fire Island Pines Restaurants in Ocean Beach
Restaurants in Fair Harbor Restaurants in Kismet


Flynns
Cuisines: American
Rum JAC Rum
Cuisines: Caribbean, Seafood
Schooner Inn
Cuisines: American
Ranked #18 in Fire Island, NY


Restaurants near Fire Island



CJ's Restaurant & Bar
Price*: US$ 50
Cuisines: American, Bar, Sandwiches, Delicatessen, Pub
Ranked #2 in Ocean Beach, NY
Hideaway Restaurant
Price*: US$ 31-40
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #5 in Ocean Beach, NY
Matures
Cuisines: Seafood
The Landing
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #13 in Ocean Beach, NY
Rachel's Bakery and Restaurant
Price*: US$ 1-20
Cuisines: Cafe
Ranked #3 in Ocean Beach, NY
Albatross
Price*: US$ 1-20
Cuisines: American
Ranked #11 in Ocean Beach, NY
Castaway Bar & Grill
Ranked #12 in Ocean Beach, NY
Hero Shop
Cuisines: Delicatessen
Town Pizza
Cuisines: Pizza
Ranked #9 in Ocean Beach, NY
The Island Mermaid
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #4 in Ocean Beach, NY
Michael's Ristorante & Pizzeria
Price*: US$ 17-32
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza, Seafood, Pasta, Healthy
Ranked #1 in Ocean Beach, NY
Houser's Bar
Ranked #10 in Ocean Beach, NY
Matthew's Seafood House
Price*: US$ 21-30
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #8 in Ocean Beach, NY
Maguire's Bay Front Restaurant
Ranked #7 in Ocean Beach, NY
Bocce Beach Restaurant
Price*: US$ 1-20
Ranked #15 in Ocean Beach, NY
Scoops
Ranked #6 in Ocean Beach, NY
Flynn's Fire Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #16 in Ocean Beach, NY
Kismet Inn
Ranked #2 in Kismet, NY
Surfs Out
Cuisines: International
Ranked #1 in Kismet, NY
Floyd's
Ranked #4 in Cherry Grove, NY
Sweet Licks Ice Cream
Sayville, Long Island. 5 km east of Fire Island
Ranked #40 in Sayville, NY
Top of the Bay
Cuisines: International
Ranked #1 in Cherry Grove, NY
Cherry's On The Bay
Ranked #14 in Ocean Beach, NY
Sandcastle on the Ocean
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #6 in Cherry Grove, NY
Island Breeze
Cuisines: American
Ranked #2 in Cherry Grove, NY
Cherry Grove Pizza
Ranked #3 in Cherry Grove, NY
Jumping Jack's Seafood Shack
Price*: US$ 1-20
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Bayside Clam Bar & Grill
East Islip, Long Island. 7 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #8 in East Islip, NY
Sand Castle on the Ocean
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #5 in Cherry Grove, NY
The Pines Bistro and Martini Bar
Cuisines: French, Bistro
Ranked #1 in Fire Island Pines, NY
George Martin's Strip Steak
Great River, Long Island. 9 km north of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 30-50
Cuisines: Steakhouse
Ranked #1 in Great River, NY
Great River Deli
Great River, Long Island. 9 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Delicatessen
Ranked #3 in Great River, NY
Sunset Restaurant
Islip, Long Island. 9 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #19 in Islip, NY
Captree Cove Restaurant & Catering
Babylon, Long Island. 9 km west of Fire Island
Ranked #22 in Babylon, NY
View
Oakdale, Long Island. 9 km north of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 31-50
Cuisines: American
Ranked #2 in Oakdale, NY
Lessing's Incorporated
Great River, Long Island. 9 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #4 in Great River, NY
Snapper Inn
Oakdale, Long Island. 9 km north of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 24-35
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #4 in Oakdale, NY
Vanderbilt's Wharf
Oakdale, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #16 in Oakdale, NY
Captree Cove Fish House
Babylon, Long Island. 10 km west of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 1-20
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #52 in Babylon, NY
Kleiber's Delicatessen
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Delicatessen
Ranked #15 in Islip, NY
Stanley's Bakery
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #2 in East Islip, NY
Vinnies Mulberry Street
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #3 in East Islip, NY
Carvel Ice Cream Bakery
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza, Pasta
Ranked #10 in East Islip, NY
Arizona Gourmet Deli
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Delicatessen
Francesco's Trattoria
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Ranked #15 in East Islip, NY
Martino's Pizza
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #18 in East Islip, NY
Hometown Cafe
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: American, Diner
Ranked #7 in East Islip, NY
Rita's Italian Ice
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Italian
Ranked #4 in East Islip, NY
The Mess Tent Cheesesteaks
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Steakhouse
Ranked #16 in East Islip, NY
Vinnie's Mulberry Street
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Pizza
Ranked #6 in East Islip, NY
Dunkin' Donuts
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
in season
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Friendly's
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
East Islip Bagel
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #19 in East Islip, NY
Shandon Court
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 29-31
Cuisines: European
Ranked #11 in East Islip, NY
Boston Market
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: American
Avicolli's Pasta House Bar
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
LAN Sing Chinese Kitchen
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Chinese
Quiznos
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #20 in East Islip, NY
Domino's Pizza
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Pizza
A S Italian Fine Foods
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: Italian, Seafood
Ranked #12 in East Islip, NY
Yan Min Kitchen
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #17 in East Islip, NY
Baskin-Robbins
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Dunkin' Donuts
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Ranked #14 in East Islip, NY
Coopersmith's Restaurant
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Jackson Hall
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: American
Ranked #9 in East Islip, NY
Beach Tree Cafe
East Islip, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 15-20
Cuisines: American
Ranked #13 in East Islip, NY
Kingston's Clam Bar
West Sayville, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 15-35
Cuisines: American, Seafood
Ranked #6 in West Sayville, NY
Nicky's On the Bay
Bay Shore, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #35 in Bay Shore, NY
Lessing Incorporated
Oakdale, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Cuisines: Cafe, Diner
Hoi Ming Restaurant Incorporated
West Sayville, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Ranked #1 in West Sayville, NY
Fortune Cookies Chinese Food
Oakdale, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Cuisines: Chinese
Ranked #17 in Oakdale, NY
Mama's Pizza Pasta & Seafood
Oakdale, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza, Seafood
Ranked #10 in Oakdale, NY
O-Co-Nee East Diner Restaurant
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: American
Ranked #5 in Islip, NY
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods
West Sayville, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #4 in West Sayville, NY
Onsen Sushi
Oakdale, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Cuisines: Sushi
Ranked #1 in Oakdale, NY
Bay Shore Marina Snack Bar
Bay Shore, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
The Hidden Oak Cafe
Great River, Long Island. 10 km north of Fire Island
Cuisines: American
Ranked #2 in Great River, NY
Fat Fish Bar & Bistro
Bay Shore, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #20 in Bay Shore, NY
Vege Favor
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Port Royal Grille
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Scotty's Pub
West Sayville, Long Island. 10 km northeast of Fire Island
Cuisines: Pub
Ranked #7 in West Sayville, NY
Treme
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Ranked #8 in Islip, NY
Manhattan Sweets Boutique Bkry
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Ranked #4 in Islip, NY
Captain Bill's
Bay Shore, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 31-40
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #16 in Bay Shore, NY
Medley's
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 10-30
Cuisines: American, Bar, Spanish, Pub, Tapas
Verace
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 31-50
Cuisines: Italian
Ranked #3 in Islip, NY
Lily Flanagan's
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Ranked #21 in Islip, NY
Tellers
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Steakhouse
Ranked #2 in Islip, NY
Gino's Tuscany Restaurant
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Italian, Pizza
Ranked #9 in Islip, NY
Long Island Cooking
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Ranked #12 in Islip, NY
Scoops Ice Cream & Yogurt
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Price*: US$ 1-20
Cuisines: Fast food
Ranked #20 in Islip, NY
Poppy's Luncheonette
Islip, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cool Water Grill
Bay Shore, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Cuisines: Seafood
Ranked #54 in Bay Shore, NY
Swept Away
Bay Shore, Long Island. 10 km northwest of Fire Island
Ranked #25 in Bay Shore, NY