Stayed for a long weekend while we were here for a wedding. We enjoyed the private, back apartment with our 3 young kids. The nights were great as we walked all around downtown with the kids, came back to the Nesbitt for drinks on the back porch, and slept like babies in the comfy beds! Two bars were right out... more

I recently went for an overnight with a friend who grew up on the island and returns once a year or so. The reviews I read concerned me a bit, but my friend assured me that he had been going there for years, and while basic, it was acceptable, and a real bargain compared to nearby properties. I went expecting... more

We stayed here for two nights this past weekend and it was not worth the money they are charging. The furniture is old and rickety and the beds are terrible! The matresses haven't been changed since probably 1982. I slept poorly and so did the rest of my family who stayed there. Had I known about the poor sleeping situation,... more

Have you ever gone to an establishment for years and looked around one day and said "This has got to be one of the worst places on the island!" admittedly it happened to me just this year! If you want to feel like your business is unappreciated go here! All of the furniture here is not second hand- it is... more

How many times has this happened to you - you check into a hotel, stay there a couple nights, and then come back one night to find someone else staying in your room? I know... it happens all the time. Oh, wait, no it doesn't. While we stayed at the Nesbitt Inn, the crotchety old owner managed to rent out... more

Since the new generation has taken over the Nesbitt Inn in 2006, it has been redecorated and renovated as time and budget permit. Steve Marcoux, a fourth generation Nantucketer and his wife , Joanne, have thrown themselves into their beloved Inn with gusto and charm. It is close to everything, the right price and comes with such saavy host couple... more

Inn is nice- Victorian, but very noisy. We had the front room- young people drunk blasting music until the wee hours. Sign in room says call the police on the cell phone if you are unhappy about the noise. I got news for you- I don't pay money for a weekend retreat so I have to call the "cops". That's... more

This place is worse than a hostel. While I enjoy hostels, I don't like staying in one for $100 a night, especially if it's advertised to be something else. There are NO LOCKS on any of the doors. Not the front door, not the room doors, nothing. This became an issue during our stay when another guest mistook our room... more

Nantucket is summer vacation land to the wealthy and so it can be incredibly difficult to find accomodations that are reasonable, period. To find accomodations that are reasonable *and* nice seems laughable. Until I found the Nesbitt Inn. This is without a doubt the *BEST* Bang for the Buck on Nantucket! Trust me, I've checked around. This Bed & Breakfast... more