We've stayed at the Algoma Beach Motel numerous times in the last seven years and have some wonderful memories. However, the in the last few years we have seen nothing but decline. Current owners refuse to do basic "upkeep" like cleaning carpets, replacing worn out towels and bedding, etc. We have pleaded with them to no avail. This motel has... More

My wife and I stopped here on our vacation traveling through Wi. The room had a terrible smell, The carpet was stained and dirty, The beds are rock hard and we both tossed and turned all night. Everything in this room reeked. This is the worst motel I have ever stayed at. I would not recommend this place for anyone.

This could be a GREAT place, located right on the beach of Lake Michigan. But the rooms are so old and SO dirty, and moreover, SO OVERPRICED that I doubt we will stay here again. The carpets were filthy. Broken Venetian blinds on the windows, old bedding, sagging beds, cheap, filthy dirty tables -- one table in our room would... More

I usually ride my bicycle to Door County each summer. Algoma is one of my usual stops. I usually stay in a different (very basic) hotel, but because my wife driving along with me this year I decided to try the Algoma Beach Hotel since she loves the water. I saw all the bad reviews but booked it booked it... More

This place is awful! The room was smelly when we walked in. We weren't even sure if the sheets were changed, there was a pile of sand next to the t.v. so they didn't clean very good. The towels were grungy and had stains on them, no hair dryer. This might be a good place for fishermen who don't care... More

This was a "spur of the moment" decision to stay here as we had changed our minds & decided to travel around door county for two days instead of just one. Our room rate was $146.00 and we were told it was last room. We walked in and put down some things and immediatedly went to dollar store. I had... More

We stayed at the end of the season (late Oct) and had a dog, but the rate for 2 nights was still $250.00! The room was clean, but that is about all that I can say about it. Oh, and the view of the lake off the deck was nice. The blanket/sheets were thread bare, mattress very uncomfortable, towels were... More

Clean rooms but only very basic and small. The towels had shreds and holes. The tv channels could only be adjusted down - had to turn off tv to get higher channels. The front desk clerk could use some professional customer service training.

We stayed at this motel after a few days with the Grandkids "phew!" We needed it and this was the perfect place. Its on beautiful lake Michigan with a wonderful big beach. Plenty of fire pits with with comfortable chairs to unwind in...and the view breathtaking! We are average joes so the room was a little pricey for the quality... More