We stayed only one night at this Inn, and I wished it was longer. We were offered a free upgrade upon checking in. The staff was very friendly and helpful. The grounds were kept immaculate and the beach is stunning. Yes, the rooms are on the small side and dated, but very clean and comfortable. If you want to relax... more

The studio room was well equiped. The view of beach & ocean was postcard perfect. The staff was friendly, knowledgable and good at their jobs. The grounds are clean and well maintained. Our only complaint was weather (act of God) which was the coldest 2 weeks in the history of the Keys. more

Yellowtail Inn was exactily what we were looking for. We wanted a place where we could take our dog, cook a few meals to save money, and also enjoy the beach. It was perfect. We are scuba divers. The Yellowtail is close to great dive facilities and offered a nice patio, big enough to dry out our scuba gear without... more

Our return visit to the Yellowtail was great, as usual. It has a perfect location -- there is no better... it's right on the ocean!! -- and very friendly service by all the staff. Accomodations are not luxurious, but you're in the heart of the Keys, so you shouldn't be spending a lot of time in your room anyway! We'll... more

Nice setting, nice pools and great service. Nice room and get this - has coffee maker, microwave even toaster. This was super convenient as we were trying to conserve money. The beach is great, got seaweed (but it was little windy that day so perhaps this has had something to do with it) About the prices you would expect in... more

The Keys is definitely known for having older hotels with no frills at slightly high prices. This hotel by no means is anything fancy and it is definitely an older hotel that has been beat up by lovers of the sea and pets. We selected the efficiency room #107 because it was the least expensive. I expected the small pool,... more

We were visiting the Florida Keys for quiet relaxation, seeing wildlife (Birding Festival), taking photographs and generally getting away from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. From our hotel we did not expect a all amenities included resort. The Yellowtail Inn is a no frills property. It is OLD Florida. The beach is not bad... anyone who lives in... more

The Yellowtail Inn was exactly what I was looking for for a family vacation. Not fancy, but right on the beach with a view of the water. We have a 3 year old and this was a perfect beach for him. The water is shallow for a long way out which some may not like but it was perfect for... more

The Yellowtail Inn was a total disappointment. The room (cottage 106) was nasty with animal odors, animal hair, sand fleas and filty when we arrived. The beach was nasty with a strong odor that smelled like sewage. The water has a grassy sea weed that intangles on your body and there is no wave action to bring fresh sea water... more