Stayed at Sugarloaf Lodge early May 2013 with family, pulling up to Lodge you are thrown back into the 70's to early 80's, they actually have hard keys to the rooms. Upon entering, you are met with a 60's style themed room, beds were extremely nice and comfortable, view was terrific overlooking the Gulf. A/C system woked actually too well... More

Excellent location right on the water. Key west is only 17 miles south and Bahia Honda state park is about the same distance north so for us it was a perfect location. Very reasonably priced especially compared to Key West. The room was very clean, and personally I found the decor charming. Like going on vacation back in time, but... More

First of all, the location of the Sugar Loaf Lodge is absolutely lovely. It's right on the water, and there's a dock if you have a boat. But if you plan to actually go inside and use your room, be warned that everything else about it is grimey and poorly-maintained. My visit began with room keys (actual KEYS, not cards)... More

This place is a great alternative to the high prices in Key West. Close enough to the Key West action without the chaos, noise and throngs of people. The price is right, the accomodations clean and good, everything you need to spend time there without going to KW, staff helpful and friendly. The rolle-away bed needs to be updated. Would... More

The lodge is perfect for us, not stuffy, lot's of locals hang out at the Tiki and the room decor is like stepping into a time machine, but in a good way. Beautiful water views right out your door and convenient to everything. Great Bar with great characters and must give the cleaning staff a shout out, my daughter caught... More

We just went to the Keys for a few days. I planned to stay in Key West but the prices were very high and since we planned to do a lot of sightseeing we thought the money would be wasted. We looked for a place close enough to Key West to drive in to the town and at a reasonable... More

Sugarloaf Lodge is actually on Sugarloaf Key. It doesn't look fancy on the outside. However, once you step into the lobby, you know it is a nice place. Very cute room with tropical mural on wall, very large Western King bed which was comfy with fridge right on the water. One note: room did not have a blow dryer or... More

tired of traffic into Key West we took a chance and stopped at Sugarloaf Lodge and got their last room. All the good things you read in their reviews are true but the best part is their setting right on the open water. Rather than being stuck in a hermetically sealed room we were able to open the sliders and... More

The Sugarloaf Lodge is one of those places you would probably pass by if you were looking for a place to stay and hadn't planned ahead. That would be your loss. Although it doesn't look like many of the modern chain motels it is a wonderful place to stay. Family owned for forty years, the rooms are neat and clean,... More