We stayed here 4 nights and found it to be an excellent choice and value. Sunsets from the property are fabulous. A real old-time FLorida Keys feel. The efficiency room we occupied was spacious and well maintained. Contrary to another review we had a comfortable kIng bed (and I am relatively hard-to-please in this regard). More

It's difficult for me to read some of these reviews. My husband and I love staying at Atlantic Bay. We live on the water and going to this "resort" makes us feel like we are at home. I certainly don't expect it to look like my house; this is not why we go there. We are more interested in the... More

Was our first trip to the Keys and booked this place sight unseen except for internet site. Very good price and beautiful grounds. My husband and I stayed in efficiency room and it was very large, clean and loved having the kitchen to make our own meals. Our only complaint was the bed was incredibly uncomfortable, probably the worse we've... More

We stayed in one of the one bedroom rooms on the top floor. Nice and quiet at night, great sunsets, spacious, close to local beaches and restaurants. Our only complaint would have been their beach on the weekends. Their was a group of kids blaring music so we ended up going to a public beach down the road as opposed... More

My family and I booked this cottage (really MOTEL) for August 2011 on the Internet because it looked so nice. I noticed a couple bad reviews but decided to stay anyway. When we arrived, it was awful. Reasons why: 1. Our whole patio was filled with bird poop, including the birds themselves which were roosters, hens, and peacocks. 2. The... More

If you are a diver, fisherman or just love the keys, this is a great place to stay. Nice clean efficiency apartment with a comfortable bed, plenty of room and a well appointed kitchen. Good facilities for boaters, and a pool satisfactory for taking a dip before dinner. If you appreciate the area for its access to great water sports,... More

I've seen most of the positive reviews on this one and I have to agree with what they have said. THIS is the laid back Keys style hotel that the keys are known for, If you require something fancy or think having free shampoo in the bathrooms makes the trip then go to a chain that looks and feels exactly... More

the place was beautiful however the "manager" some lady there literally kicked my entire family out and i know rules are rules but she lied and said a number of people which when i read the fine print it says 20$ per person which we didnt mind paying but her exact words were " we dont want your money we... More

We had the pleasure of spending 5 wonderful days at the Atlantic Bay Resort. It was one of the most relaxing and beautiful places I've ever been. From the peacocks and peahens roaming the property to finding coconuts on the beach in the mornings....it was like stepping back in time to an island paradise. It's a no-frills place, so don't... More