Stayed in the Garrison House Tack room. Paper thin walls and ceilings. You could hear everything in each room. I mean everything. Let you imagination run wild. No sleep, uncomfortable bed and noise level keep you awake. If I am going to pay that much for a room for one night, I expect to not hear my neighbors all night... More

We stopped by on a weekday late morning for breakfast / lunch. The dining room was half full. As we were seated, the Hostess informed us that they only had one server scheduled so we would unfortunately be waiting for a while before we were helped. Sure enough, it was over 10 minutes before we were even acknowledged by the... More

We were leaving the Abe Martin Lodge and I had seem something about the Storey Inn so we decided to find it. It was a nice drive but maybe not at night. Not really a town but we really liked the Inn. We took a lot of pictures and went in to see what there was. The inside was really... More

My husband and I married in his hometown of Columbus, Indiana (we live in California), and booked our 2-night Indiana honeymoon here. We had such a fantastic time that we returned last summer to stay overnight again. I hate to give away our accommodation secret but here it is: The Old Mill Loft. I just love it! Sure, the bathtub... More

I am not sure what happened to make the few reviews before mine be so poor. I have now been to the Story Inn twice. Last year my husband and I went with another couple during the Victorian Candlelight Christmas. The meal was so delicious --the fillet--that we decided to go again this year. While the boys had been drooling... More

We had stayed at Story one night a year or so ago and that went well; however, on this trip, when we went to our room after checking in at 9:00 PM, we found all the lights were on, the heat was turned on high and the door to an adjacent room was unlocked and wide open. Obviously, someone had... More

I normally loved the Story Inn... but that all changed the day I got engaged to my beautiful fiancee. The day was a perfect fall setting in Brown County State Park where I popped the question. I had made reservations in the Story Inn's new cabins. It was such a wonderful day but when we arrived at the inn we... More

Forget those drugs, go to Story...Take a step back in time and just RELAX. We just spent our 18th and what a great time we had. NO tv, NO phones just pure time to ourselves. We had a room with a hot tub and many many candles and what romantic evenings we enjoyed. The staff are fantastic, the food WOW.... More

This place was so much fun! Five dear friends and family females stayed in the Wheeler Homestead back on a Friday overnight. Every person we ran into at dinner and the bar were super friendly. We had drinks with the owner and the bulider of all the unique structures throughout the tiny town. The restaurant was relaxing and the food... More