Hickory Grove is an inexpensive little motel on a beautiful lake near Cooperstown. The staff was very accommodating when we asked for advice on restaurants and extra pillows. This is not a fancy place, but you can't beat if for the price.

My rating is based on expectations for a roadside motel. I thought this motel fit the bill for $80/night in a room with two double beds. Reliable Wi-Fi, a nice view, windows that open and about a 10 minute drive to Cooperstown. The mattresses were ok, there was a small fridge in the room which worked well. An update to... More

Quaint, comfortable and clean. I would prefer this place to a five star hotel. Absolutely great staff. There are no coffee pots in the rooms but the office made a pot of coffee just for me this evening!! There are only 12 units so it is quiet and peaceful. Our room has a beautiful view of the lake. About a... More

Great little motel, friendly staff, and easy to find. Don't let Google maps fool you, though - it's a bit further up Lake Otesaga than the address directs. Not sure why the other reviewers thought the shower was small - seemed to be a normal size to me and my heavy-set husband.

This place has all the basic amenities, but I think there might be better choices in the area and for the same price range. The staff is friendly, and the rooms, though small, are adequate. However, we found some issues related to cleanliness in the room that made us wonder. Most of the issues were minor. One of the beds... More

Room was adequate. Had everythyng you would need. Bathroom was clean, but found hair on sheet. Greeted cleaning lady, who seemed grouchy. Man running office was very friendly and very helpful when asking about Hall of Fame. Not far from Cooperstown Village, just tricky to find for first time if it's dark. Good price for summer season.

This little motel was a little out-dated, but clean and comfortable. Nice staff, short drive to Cooperstown, and had a very nice picnic on their private beach. Though a little small, I'm not sure what rooms other reviewers had. I'm a big guy (6' 1', 260) , but can still sleep with my wife on a double bed. Our son... More

clean and comfortable room, very small stand up shower, breakfast consisted of bagels, donuts, coffee and OJ. Nice picnic area with tables and Adirondack chairs. nice view of the lake from our room. this motel is not directly on the lake, but you can see it from the rooms and outdoor area. lake access is provided by a gravel road... More

The people who worked here were very nice. I loved the walk down to the water and the paddle boat was great for the kids. However - the room barely held two double beds and it was much too small to accomodate 2 adults, and a 9 and 12 yr old. The 12 yr old slept on the floor and... More