Stayed an early September Saturday night this weekend and found the property to be clean, neat, and just the right amount of casual. My spouse and I enjoyed the ability to go with the local flow, instead of a predictable chain experience. Lakeside cottage themed rooms with comfy beds, tasteful antiques, and quite the nice sunset. Fair Haven Beach park... More

I was infatuated with staying at this hotel. I stumbled upon it online while looking for a nice place to stay while near Sterling for the Renaissance Festival. There were TONS of reviews about how wonderful and beautiful and cozy this hotel was. The photos were beautiful. I could not WAIT and was pleased to find out when I called... More

I drove up to Fair Haven last night with a friend to catch the sunset and have dinner on the water. The best place to do this is Pleasant Beach Hotel. It had been a very hot humid uncomfortable day at home and we had hoped to find some relief from that. The light on the water was just perfect... More

Made to order included breakfast. Cozy rooms with sleep # beds. Fun nightime atmosphere. Great food for any meal! Close to Fair Haven State Park. Walking distance to other bars and main street. Lovely view!

I loved this place. More like a B & B than a hotel, but it has kept the 100 year old name, "Pleasant Beach Hotel". If you appreciate history, you will find the "junktique" style of decorating very interesting. We were shocked by the "made to order" breakfast after having continental breakfast in every other place we stayed. Hospitality, character... More

If you are looking for snooty, uptight or pretentious, this is NOT for you! The Pleasant Beach Hotel is a hidden jewel,complete with unmatched views of the lake, exceptional food and drink and a staff that makes you right at home. The second floor wrap-around balcony has comfy chairs and a great hammock that make the perfect place to enjoy... More

This place took my breath away. When I first walked around the rooms and met the people in the restaurant and the owners, I could not stop smiling. If quaint is what you're looking for, this is definitely the plqce to go. After a week in dc and nyc, 4 nights here by the lake were exactly what we needed.

We loved this place. Lots of cozy chairs to sit out and watch a sunset by Little Sodus Bay. As an Oswego native I was so happy to find a place nearby where we could relax, and then we got great tips about a good boat rental so we got to be out on the lake as well. The state... More

My husband and I stayed here for our 5 year anniversary. Our room was very nice (yellow with a multicolored quilt. It was pretty clean, too. The window didn't open, but there was a steady stream of air conditioning blowing in and a ceiling fan. The Sleep Number bed was fun to use, too! Meals were delicious! We ate breakfast... More