We read lots of bad reviews about the Grand Islander and were pleasantly surprised to find it was perfectly normal. Basically like a Comfort Inn or Red Roof. We came on a weekend and already knew that all the lodging is more expensive on the weekend. Its an island, they get away with that as long as people keep coming.... More

My husband and I traveled here back in April for a business event at the convention center. Upon arrival there were space heaters going because the heat wasn't working. After getting our key cards, we tried to get into our room but couldn't. Maintenance couldn't even get us into our room! The door looked like someone had beat it with... More

My bathroom smeeled like vomit. Many fixtures broke. Very damp and unsantary. All the doors were dented. AC did not work well. The staff was nice but over all a terribly maintained hotel. Very dissapointed.

The location is fantastic but you have to get past the Jersey Shore of Lake Erie crowd first. "Yo Pauly, can I ged anuda round a beers over ear?" Take the place at face value and let's be honest. This is an over-priced college dorm with a swim-up bar and a pirate ship. The sheets were stained, the AC was... More

I was not the person who chose this hotel to stay for a bachlorette party from Thursday- Sunday. There were 10 people staying in 2 rooms each with a king bed and a couch bed. The overall look of the hotel is very cheap. The hallways are not airconditioned and smelled of cat urine. There is a nightclub at the... More

The hotel rooms were not very nice, kind of dingy, especially for the $200 per night cost in the summer on the weekend. BUT the hotel is very fun since its one block away from the main street in Put In Bay and has 4 or 5 pools, some with DJ's and most with pool bars. I would recommend splitting... More