Many choices on the menu. Waitstaff was very informative when questions were asked regarding menu items. Good service. We ate lunch here and was not disappointed. A little on the pricier side for the location of the restaurant (in a strip mall), but we would definitely return.

I used to love this restaurant. I then went on a Friday night and was told that it would be a 90 minute wait. I then looked down on the list, and saw that there were several names with a box around the names and VIP written next to their names. Please remember that this is Appleton WI, not NYC... More

Carmela’s continues to be the premier eateries in the Fox Valley. Despite its inauspicious location, the food is outstanding. My wife always orders the chicken parm and is never disappointed. I like to experiment with one of the daily specials and am extremely satisfied. True, the prices are a little higher than some other restaurants in the Valley, but so... More

We went to Carmeiia's for lunch and had such a wonderful meal we went back for dinner the same day. It was the best meal I have ever eaten. The service is top notch and everyone so friendly and helpful with picking out a superb meal. This place will always be a stop I make. When I'm in Appleton.

Well rounded menu. Food is really high quality. The service is really friendly too. I love their arugula salad. I tried their panini, a little on the greasy side

Don't mind the outside appearance of this Bistro or its chain store neighbors. This is a locally owned and very well-run restaurant. Indeed, the fact that dining in Appleton is fairly grim definitely elevates one's perception of food quality and atmosphere at Carmella's. However, this little gem holds a well-deserved designation as Appleton's darling. Pasta is cooked perfectly al dente.... More

We've eaten at Carmella's twice and have not been disappointed. The food is excellent, the wine selection is excellent and we've had great service both times. This has become our "must-visit" restaurant when in Appleton.

We ate here as a couple and absolutely were impressed! I had been here before but came with my husband this time. The food was amazing. I was glad I tried something new cause now I have a new favorite! I thought they had a great selection of wine although we only got a chance to try two. We came... More

We ate at Carmella's several times now and enjoyed it very much basically every single time. The last time we went was for my graduation dinner. I made a reservation about a week ago and requested to be on the outside porch if possible. They cannot guarantee a spot, but they gave it to me when the day came without... More