Go here for mostly for the meatball or chicken parm sandwiches. If you like a hot sandwich would give a try.
We were looking for a quick meal that could be delivered to our room on the night of our arrival. The pizza was delivered hot and fresh. The wait time for delivery was minimal. If you want great pizza while staying on Manasota Key, you should definitely give Geraldi's a try.
Great food!! Their pizza is the best and we always look forward to getting one when we go to Englewood Beach.
We ordered pizza delivery from this place while on vacation. They only provide delivery service to the Manasota Key area, so it was very convenient for us. We ordered 2 medium pizzas, one with only cheese and the other with pepperoni, onion, mushrooms, green pepper and cheese. Both pizzas were very good and were hot on delivery. The only negative... More
Ample serving of very good italian food and pizza with average service during winter months and above average service at other times. Value pricing has winter snowbirds "sitting in line" every night in winter.
We've been here several times the last two years and haven't had a bad pizza! They have a tiny tiny outdoor seating area, so we usually pick it up and take it over the picnic area at Englewood beach. Delicious pizza and reasonable prices. The pasta salad is good as well!
Good enough pizza to make everyone happy! We only got one pizza (a pepperoni) so I can't comment on much, however, they were quick and the take out service was great! The kids loved the pizza and the crust.
After a long day of travel and arriving late in the day, we decided to order a pizza and eat at our condo. The crust is a traditional thin crust, which is not my favorite style. The pizza came with plenty of toppings and cheese, with a nice slightly tangy sauce. We would definitely eat here again when we return... More
Looking for a quick pizza and with no local knowledge we relied on Trip Advisor and the reviews favored Geraldi's. Great choice; the reviews were correct. The place is tiny and take-out only. The cook only has room to prepare one pie at a time and limited oven space but he's very quick and efficient. We ordered a large (18")... More
If you own or manage Geraldi's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing