Butterfly Cafe is a very classy restaurant. Reservations are required. I made reservations a week in advance for our anniversary dinner. The ambience was romantic and overall classy. The garden is just beautiful! My husband and I absolutely loved our dinner. I did not order dessert since I prefer my key lime pie plain not with a chocolate crust. We... More

Enough variety of interesting menu items to go back many times in one week. Spicy foods were enjoyable even for someone with low heat tolerance. Appreciated gluten free options including dessert.

We were looking for a nice place that had outdoor setting and the Butterfuly Cafe came up with great reviews, so we tried it. Boy, were we in for a treat. First off, the restaurant is at the Tranquility Bay Resort, which is just gorgeous, very clean and peaceful. We were seated outside with a view of the lush gardens... More

We stayed in the resort connected to the restaurant (tranquility bay). This place is awesome! We are going to have to force ourselves to branch out and eat elsewhere occasionally during our stay. Kudos to the chef for offering an extensive gluten free menu (I have celiac disease). The scallops risotto were to die for! We also ordered and loved... More

We ate at the Butterfly Cafe for dinner during our stay at Tranquility Bay Resort. It is a small restaurant with outside porch tables as well. We chose the porch since it was beautiful weather. Reservations are highly recommended as this is a small place. I had the Butterfly Salad it was fresh and delicious. We also ordered the grouper... More

I have been coming to Marathon for 35 years and this is the best restaurant on the island! My wife and I were greeted with wonderful service, a porch view/setting, and enjoyed a meal that was outstanding! This truely is a place where the employees feel a part of the business and it shows in their hospitality, even towards those... More

This was our second trip to dine at the Butterfly cafe and again were so pleased with meal, ambiance and service. Cheryl was a great server, professional but very friendly. Food again excellent. And the setting is so romantic, especially sitting outside dining after dark. Worth every penny and then some! Don't miss a dinner a meal here.

Romantic and relaxing atmosphere on the back porch for dining. Mahi mahi was absolutely delicious as was the coconut shrimp. Our server offered a special gluten free menu for me which was much appreciated. Many selections to choose from in GF categories too.

My husband and I stopped here on our way back to Islamorada after leaving Bahia Honda. We were a bit confused finding the cafe. It is the one and only building as soon as you pull into tranquility bay resort. There is no obvious signage, only next to the door after you have parked and walked up to the building.... More