We absolutly love this place!! They have the best pizza ever. We drove from Daytona just to eat here. I have never had such an Awesome pizza as this. It's always perfect! The waitstaff is always friendly too. It's like eating ay home. We have been here numerous times over the years & They always are welcoming. Eat here for... More

You must go here for the best pizza and the best service. Do not be decieved by the location. It is wonderful. Service is down home and friendly. Ask David to turn a one doller bill into two. They are freindly and amaising and grat Pizza.

After a tour of St Augustine we stopped for quick bite we stopped at Carmelos and grabbed pizza. It was excellent and the service was great. Good value and great pizza

We've never been disappointed with the pizza here. The veggie and the Marguerita are notable and ten large pizza is huge. They now have a wood fired grill as an option for finishing your pizza and I highly recommend it. The prices are good and, if you eat in, the servers are very nice and attentive. There are other menu... More

Do not let the gas pumps outside fool you. Being from NY they sell one of the better tasting pizzas in the area.

What a place! We ordered takeout pizza tonight (Carmelo's Supreme) and it was just the best best best! A 16" was generously covered with delicious toppings on an amazingly delicious crust and half is left for the 2 of us tomorrow! I generally like pizza anyway but this was 1st place by a mile! Friendly staff too!

This is the best pizza ever! We ordered the 20" pizza and it was huge. The ingredients were yummy and fresh and no skimping here...Beware... though, this place gets very busy and is better to do take out, unless you arrive early. We loved it so much, we had it on Friday night and came back on Sunday at opening... More

Do not eat here!!!! The pizza is decent however the waitress in the resturant was extremely rude and thats putting it nicely. Being from out of town we were unfamiliar with the area and this resturant which is connected to a gas station. We entered through the ga staion and went to the counter to order and sit in there.... More

We love Carmellos. It feels like our neighborhood grocery / pizzaria where they recognize us when we come in and it feels good. Clean, bright, lots of choices.