We ordered a Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza and the toppings were just in the center and not all the way around the pizza even, Not impressed.
Went to visit Shipshewana, IN with a couple of young friends and family.. went to this place as this was one of the few restaurants in town within about 15-20 miles of the area.. we just ordered a few veggie pizzas and garlic bread with cheese... the pizza was ok, but the garlic bread was AWESOME!! Will definitely eat here... More
We arrived on a Sunday evening, and had a choice of this place and Subway. Was grateful they were open. We got there around 8, and they had the remains of a buffet. Salad bar was pretty decent. Iceberg lettuce, but fresh peppers, mushrooms, onions, tomatoes, and many other items to make a decent salad. Pizzas had been on the... More
If late night is 7:00 on Sunday evening. Only two places are open on Sunday: East of Chicago and Subway. We liked EofC. What can I say. Service was very good and the food was good, if not stellar.
In their lunch buffet, I was able to try a chicago style and the regular thin crust pizza. As a cheese lover, the chicago style was pretty tasty, not just the regular dose of mozarella. Marinara sauce was a little sweet, not as tangy as the sauce on the thin crust. Pretty good deal for the money.
I'm never disappointed with my experience. Not only is the food delicious, they use REAL mushrooms. I hate the canned ones, so every trip to East of Chicago is heaven!!
We showed up to eat here on a Friday evening. The staff here was also very unfriendly. Then, once we had paid, they did not have ONE pizza made for the buffet. We had to wait for pizza to get made and once it was done, everyone ran to get a slice. They were not able to keep up with... More
Maybe we just stopped in on an off day, but as12:30 pm there were only two partial pizzas on the bar. We sorted through many dirty plates in the stacks that had baked on food leftover from the dishwasher. I made a decent salad from the bar but lost my appetite when I found a hair in the lettuce after... More
If you own or manage East of Chicago Pizza, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing