Jumbo Lump Crab Salad! Absolutely delicious with great flavor. I had the halibut and my wife had the chicken. Both seasoned to perfection.
We finally found our 'foodie' experience in Cape May and also found more due to the staff. The atmosphere is of formal fine dining with exquisite food and professional service. The extra was when we needed assistance calling for a less formal interaction; my back seized. The staff morphed for the situation into really kind, reassuring, nice, personable, considerate folk... More
My husband and I really enjoyed our recent dinner at "PSI." The ambiance is very nice with a beach view, and the food is superb. I really enjoyed the butternut squash soup in particular. Highly recommend PSI for a romantic evening out.
Like dining at an an upscale Manhattan restaurant without the pomp. Decor , food and service were all excellent.
Everything is top notch at Peter Shields - the food, the service, the location, the views, and the layout of the restaurant. We've been coming here for years and it just gets better and better. Last night, I had the foie gras and the duck. The sauces are outstanding and the quinoa and vegetables with the duck were perfectly seasoned.... More
My husband and I ate here a few years back. It was just OK, I'm not sure where I heard that they have a new chef. What a culinary genius! Not only was it beautifully presented, it was in fact, the tastiest meal we have eaten in Cape May, including The Washington Inn. The service was as good as the... More
I had one of the best meals I have ever eaten here. The scallops and steak were fabulous. I would eat here every time I visit Cape May. Awesome!
Peter Shields is an excellent choice for dinner while visiting Cape May. The ambiance, the food and the service is outstanding. So much so, we had our Daughter's rehersal dinner there last year. It's always our first choice for any special occasion.
Very well done. Professional staff, enjoyed the porch location, tables close but not noisy. Menu had adequate variety to please most palates. I enjoyed soup as an appetizer, along with an entree of beef that was well prepared as requested medium rare. Dessert was slightly disappointing as it was chilled and would be better at room temperature. We will return.
If you own or manage Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing