We ordered chicken grilled salad and spaghetti to take out. The salad was very good. The spaghetti was good but not outstanding. The bread was mediocre. But the staff was very friendly & prompt with the food.

Excellent casual Itallian food. Everything is good with owners on premises. Employees very nice and helpful. BYOB

Each year when my friends & I converge on Cape May for our annual Girls Only Week, a MUST stop is Mario's for the most delicious, mouth-watering garlic knots that your imagination can fathom. The generous use of tiny garlic chunks, doughy soft bread and melted butter will ignite your senses and keep you coming back for more!

I dont even know if I would qualify this pizza as "decent". We stopped in for a couple of plain slices and were very disappointed. Tasted like cheap ingredients were used with no real seasoning or flavor. We concluded that with all the tourists in town, a place like this doesnt have to put out great pizza, they will get... More

We walked all over the Commons Mall area looking for a place to eat. Most have a menu outside to read and then you know what you are getting into when you walk inside. (nice) As we entered Mario's there was only 2 ladies sitting at a table (little did we know one was the owner or manager) As we... More

This is a good pizzeria. They had a variety of slices available both times I went here, and it was nice to be able to get two slices and a drink and have a quick and cheap dinner. They also have the other standard food, like pasta etc. They do have outdoor seating as well.

We decided to grab some pizza and head to sunset beach for the evening. We searched Tripadvisor for the best pizza in Cape May. We called and ordered some pizza for the beach trip. The pizza was hot and freshly made and the staff was great. The pizza really lacked any pizzazz. The crust was, to be honest, like cardboard... More

My husband and I stopped in Mario's duriing our vacation in Cape May. I had the vegetarian pizza and my husband had the margarita pizza. Both were excellent. The owner Mario was very hospitable and made up us feel at home. Nice place Defintely will stop at Mario's next time we visit Cape May!

We visit here what was their first day back in business (Only open during the season). I felt the wait time to get our food was a little long. They give a nice portion of food. I got a Panini which is Hot pressed on Ciabetta Bread (Which I felt was too hard for my taste). Everyone enjoyed their mail... More