Great friendly place to watch a game, meet friends, have a drink and have one of my favorite thick crust pizzas.

I typically order To-go Pizzas from this Bar about every other week. Their thick crust pizzas are out of this world tasty..(I recommend Extra Sauce and Extra Cheese though). The Inside of the Bar seems Spacious, Clean, and Attractive, I don't go to bars frequently, but this one seems inviting.

We stopped by Gem City on a Monday night after hearing that Baraboo actually had a spot offering great pizza and nachos that were beyond good. On the way in we were set for nachos. We'd heard they were house made, crispy, wafer thin, and loaded with goodies. However, once we arrived we saw two pizzas being delivered to the... More

As a "hooked on Chicago Pizza" person, when a local told me that this was the best pizza place in Wisconsin I was skeptical. Surprise, the best pizza in Wisconsin is in Baraboo! That said, I believe the pizza is not their best thing, it is the third. Number one is their home made deep fried nachos. Can not be... More

I've been to gem city a few times. The last time I tried this pizza everyone was talking about. It was very tastey and nothing like anyone else around here serves. Drinks are always good and they have a good beer selection. One of few places that has new castle on tap that I know of.....if they still do I... More

This is a new favorite of the locals! Pizzas are to die for! Ditto for the truly jumbo hamburgers. Bartenders and waitstaff really hustle and are very friendly and accomidating. Cocktails are outstanding! Atmosphere is terific in a completely remodeled warehouse AND it's conveniently located right next to Circus World Museum!