Top quality steaks and side dishes at a fair price. We drive from Payson once a month to eat there. Payson needs a steakhouse like this.
Stopped here to eat during a road trip. Was not disappointed with the food or the service. Your entree price includes soup and salad bar and ice cream for desert. I had the trout and it was wonderful. Husband had the chicken fried steak and he managed to eat every bite. The wait staff were exceptional. Will go back when... More
Our greeter was our server. Excellent service,attentive and very knowledgeable with food choice. Full bar. Ribs fall off the bone, steaks cooked to perfection. Jumbo shrimp is the size of prawns. Barrista knows how to make a drink. No draft beer. No special dessert. Complimentary scoop of vanilla I e cream with chocolate syrup. Staff took time to photo me... More
We went for dinner and experienced one disappointment after another. First we were told they were OUT OF STEAKS. No ribeyes or top sirloins and it was only 7:40 pm! Our waiter said they had been busy for the last hour and they ran out. Then he came back and informed us they were OUT OF BAKED POTATOES and only... More
We arrived at 6pm; no horseriders in the parking lot and the place was pretty quiet but the ambience was great. We were visiting from New Zealand so the game heads and western/rustic atmosphere were unique and added to the tasty meal. We enjoyed steaks cooked to our liking and the salad bar, while not extensive, was fresh and tasty.... More
I went to Horsemen Lodge with my parents in May. It was FANTASTIC!!! Super good salad bar with many excellent premade salads (including seafood salad). I had the fall of the bone ribs. They
We went to the Horseman's at 5:30 pm on a Friday. The parking lot was empty as was the dining room. Our party of 6 ordered fillets, ribeye steaks and trout. We were surprised that the salad bar did not have a full lettuce tray. Nevertheless, the salad bar was tasty. The fillets were tender, the riveted were chewy, and... More
The ambience was really neat, you don't see this many taxidermied animals every day! Steaks were perfectly cooked and juicy, all entrees came with salad bar and soup. The salad bar was nothing to write home about, but the soup was delicious. Service was great. Fun place and reasonable prices.
Big game heads and western wear hanging on the walls, the parking lot attendants were on horseback. The whole place is fun and authentic. The salad bar was surprisingly good and fresh and the applewood prime rib special was really good. Very rustic and an enjoyable experience all the way around. Chatted with the owner on the way out and... More
If you own or manage Horsemen Lodge Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.Manage your listing