Always our favorite lobster dinner for the season! Warm oven fresh rolls are mouth watering, and actually true as advertised - Mile High Lemon Pie :-)

Always our favorite lobster dinner for the season! Warm oven fresh rolls are mouth watering, and actually true as advertised - Mile High Lemon Pie :-)
There are lobster dinners and then there is New Glasgow Lobster Dinners! Fresh/ lots of food/ great desserts/friendly service and been around for years .
A true maritime tradition that remains authentic. Very busy at dinner but worth the wait. Homemade buns, salad, chowder and desserts. Try your lobster cold. All you can eat mussels...yummy. You will definitely need to leave lots of room in your tummy for this meal.
very good food, atmosphere could use work, when there are a lot of people it is hard to have a conversation.
People should have a meal at this PEI "institution" even if they will only spend a couple of days on the island. Its been here a long time and its just as good now as it was years ago. All you can eat mussels is a big hit with the big eaters and their homemade warm rolls are supurb. The...
More
Having looked up all the applicable lobster suppers available in PEI through my Lonely Planet and word-of-mouth, we decided on the New Glasgow Lobster Supper. It was a 20 minute drive from our cottage rental in Cavendish but the drive was easy and scenic. We were seated in the downstairs area since its licensed and I wanted a glass of...
More
We decided to arrive as soon as they opened, so as to avoid the crowds. After buying our meal tickets, we were made to wait behind a cordon until they were ready to admit us. After waiting for ten to fifteen minutes watching personnel prepare the tables and do cleaning!, they finally lifted the cordon.
Only, instead of letting our...
More
We visited this restaurant while on vacation in PEI. While we enjoyed our dinner and our waitress was very good, the host at the front door was not very welcoming at all. Because this was our first time, we had no idea how to order and he was no help. We were 4 adults and 3 children and two of...
More
The lobster is great. Super fresh, basic preparation, add some butter and you're golden. While the all-you-can-eat experience is fun, the rest of the food (mussels, salad, pie/ice cream) was just average. With that said, if you're looking for lobster, this is your spot!
It seemed like my Aunt, Grandma and I were the only non-bus tour there. The place was packed and after eating I can see why. We were steered this way by my Lonely Planet. The mussels were so good and if we hadn't had a whole huge lobster coming, I would've asked for more. I was completely stuffed by the...
More
If you own or manage New Glasgow Lobster Supper, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.
Manage your listing