Just came back from 2 weeks in Rome. Read Tripadvisor reviews and finally found it after a struggle with the maps. When we showed up without a reservation, we were told there wasn't room. So we made a reservation on the spot for the next night. Loved the gnocchi with chestnuts and mushrooms. Wow! Never got to the desserts since we were too full. For us, the best way to get there from Campo de Fiori was to walk about halfway up the Piazza Navona on the left hand side, then take a left down Tor Millina, where the Tre Scalini restaurant is. Keep walking a bit until you get to a little alley called Montevecchio and make a right. Keep going up, bearing left. If you get to Via de Corinari, you've gone too far.
If you own or manage Osteria del Pegno, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.