We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Review Highlights
Best Little Theater & Shows Around

We recently went to see "Fellow Travelers" this month. The performance was fantastic. Not a bad... read more

Reviewed June 27, 2018
Patchogue, New York
Stellar Performance!

We love attending productions at Bay Street Theatre and Sunday night's performance of "Fellow... read more

Reviewed June 5, 2018
Cabo San Lucas, Mexico
Read all 72 reviews
All photos (7)
Full view
Traveller Overview
  • Excellent70%
  • Very good22%
  • Average2%
  • Poor2%
  • Terrible4%
Travellers talk about
“off broadway”(2 reviews)
“tickets”(11 reviews)
Suggested duration: 1-2 hours
Local Weather
Powered by Weather Underground
Bay Street and Main Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
+1 631-725-0818
Improve This Listing
Reviews (72)
Filter reviews
72 results
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year
Show reviews that mention
All reviews fellow travelers off broadway tickets stage production musical lobby rows director play culture nyc season offerings programming stellar donation
Updating list...
1 - 10 of 72 reviews
Reviewed October 15, 2018

I purchased eleven tickets for a concert the week that they became available, which was three months before the concert date of October 13. I was lucky enough to get the first two rows, center. I had two family members traveling from out of state...More

Date of experience: October 2018
Thank Luana D
BayStreetTheater, Management at Bay Street Theatre, responded to this reviewResponded October 22, 2018

We are sorry to hear that your experience at Bay Street was anything less than perfect. We always strive to provide a positive experience for everyone who visits us. Please know that we always have employees stationed in the theater and they did offer you...More

Reviewed June 27, 2018

We recently went to see "Fellow Travelers" this month. The performance was fantastic. Not a bad seat in the house. We make it a point to attend at least one show every season. And spend the day walking Main St. and view the Harbor and...More

Date of experience: June 2018
1  Thank cannotwaittogetthere
Reviewed June 5, 2018

We love attending productions at Bay Street Theatre and Sunday night's performance of "Fellow Travelers" was yet another outstanding evening. The intimacy of the Bay Street Theatre provided the perfect setting for the world premiere of "Fellow Travelers". Extremely well written, the play flowed with...More

Date of experience: June 2018
Thank C9168CGlindam
Reviewed August 22, 2017

The Bay Street is an institution in Sag Harbor that improves programming and expands its constituency every year. The theater receives support from miles around via: fundraisers, donations and ticket sales. Their range of offerings is so diverse that I suggest you visit their website...More

Date of experience: July 2017
3  Thank swilliams889
Reviewed August 5, 2017

purchased 4 premium seats for first row but not available at show time. offered 4 alternate seats with little or no view of stage. our seats were given to favorite patrons. no explanation no apology. we left the theatre prior to show and not yet...More

Date of experience: August 2017
2  Thank tedthebroker
Reviewed July 26, 2017 via mobile

Saw an ad at the last minute that one of my favorite Broadway stars and his wife were going to be performing at Bay Street's Music Monday's. Last minutes were not plentiful, had to sit all the way on the side but the theater is...More

Date of experience: July 2017
2  Thank MUlaxmom
Reviewed July 15, 2017 via mobile

Perfect spot for evening entertainment. Nice bar and very friendly staff. Great show. Must try the Surly Penguin cordials!

Date of experience: July 2017
Thank Chris O
Reviewed July 11, 2017

I'd won 4 tickets to a show & took another couple to see Lingerie Affair. It was delightful. Very entertaining, minimal props, wonderful actors-actresses. Close-up & personal venue. Very enjoyable!

Date of experience: July 2017
Thank Kayaker318
Reviewed July 10, 2017

The Bay street Theatre presentations are truly wonderful, its always a delight, great talents are out here and perform so many times its better that in NYC. Its good to check their calendar and book your lodging reservations when you see what you want at...More

Date of experience: July 2017
Thank ElizabethMain
Reviewed June 7, 2017

Celebrated cartoonist/author Jules Feiffer and theater & composer/lyricist Andrew Lippa along with director Jeffrey Seller have turned Feiffer's children's book into an imaginative musical about a talented, lonely boy who just wants a friend and his father to love him. This is a great family...More

Date of experience: June 2017
Thank Janet S
View more reviews
Nearby HotelsSee all 5 nearby hotels
The American Hotel
123 reviews
.16 km away
Baron's Cove
298 reviews
.45 km away
Sag Harbor Inn
141 reviews
.56 km away
Topping Rose House
148 reviews
7.16 km away
Nearby RestaurantsSee all 54 nearby restaurants
The American Hotel
314 reviews
.18 km away
Page at 63 Main
281 reviews
.20 km away
Lulu Kitchen & Bar
86 reviews
.28 km away
The Beacon
112 reviews
.23 km away
Nearby AttractionsSee all 35 nearby attractions
Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum
57 reviews
.53 km away
Sag Harbor Marine Park
20 reviews
.57 km away
Havens Beach
21 reviews
1.22 km away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from Bay Street Theatre staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines