Reflects recent average nightly prices reported by our partners, and may not include estimated taxes or fees. Price at checkout may differ.
Cheaper
Average
Higher
About
3.0
#13 of 13 hotels in Christiansted
Location
Cleanliness
Service
Value
Club Comanche - Hotel St. Croix... where value and simple accommodations meet to provide you with a great experience in a prime Boardwalk location. The charming boutique hotel is placed in the center of St. Croix’ historic town of Christiansted. Established in 1756, as a townhouse for a Danish Doctor, it is one of the oldest buildings in town and has been home to the Comanche Hotel since 1948. The 28 unique rooms provide all modern amenities. Our location will put you front and center of the Christiansted Boardwalk and harbor activity plus a knockout view of the island beach at Protestant Cay, which is just a short ferry ride away. Please note that we no longer offer a pool as an amenity. While the pool form remains in place, it is in the process of being repurposed. We thank you in advance for your understanding. Kind be aware that not all reviews on this site appear to be valid. They are not verified as actual guests of the property by the hotel management and freely posted without reservation verification. The images on this website do not not reflect the latest guest experience such as social distancing of public spaces, amenities no longer offered and changes to food and beverage.
Star ratings are intended to indicate the general level of features, amenities, and services to expect. This property is classified according to Giata.
HOTEL STYLE
Historic Hotel
Romantic
Languages Spoken
English
Location
1 Strand Street, Christiansted 00820 St. Croix
Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix
168 reviews
Getting there
Great for walkers
Places to stay are graded on a 0-100 scale. The higher the grade, the easier it is for travellers to find restaurants and things to do within walking distance.
I stayed here for a very quick vacation. The check in desk is very friendly, but is only open a few hours a day. The suite is very small, no ocean view, the bed is very loud, the shower stall is very small, and the wifi cuts out in the bathroom. I don't think it's worth what I paid. The area is very touristy, so expect loud music until the long hours of the night. The hotel is very close to the pier.
Read more
Date of stay: April 2021Trip type: Travelled solo
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
You get what you pay for If you want all the thrills of a resort do not go. If you want convenient real deal experience. This place is history the moment you drive up. Originally built in 1756 you can tell you can feel it and it’s one for the memory books.
Read more
Review collected in partnership with Cancelon.com
Date of stay: December 2019Trip type: Travelled on business
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Before I start, this hotel was built in the 1700’s so it’t obviously old but throw in a couple of hurricanes and Covid over the past few years, and it’s not been treated well. I feel for these guys because the staff has been super super nice and accommodating. The property has some history, including the original hand crank elevator (obviously mo longer in use, but cool to see). There is housekeeping service and our late check in was contactless. Limited staff but the entrance requires a code. Our room had the best view (ask for corner room 29 facing the harbor). Our first room was a two story suite with a balcony and view but I think it hadn’t been occupied for some time and just needed a freshen up. We called after 8pm and the manager on call switched us right away. Easy peasy. Not a big deal. If you are looking for amenities, this is not it but we didn’t care. Pool is closed and no breakfast but plenty of places for that just outside the door. The Courtyard next door is also a full on spa with yoga and fitness classes. Fantastic place to fill the amenity void. Plus, who needs a pool when the best one on the planet is steps away? We came for the adventure and views not to stay inside and this place is in a perfect location. 40 Eats and RAW (Rum And Wine Bar) at the street level of the hotel are seriously not to be missed! Amazing food and staff. Thank you Bob and Sharif for accommodating us and being so responsive! My Birthday week has been amazing! :)
Read more
Date of stay: February 2022Trip type: Travelled as a couple
Room Tip:Parking is where you can find it on the street but we never had an issue.
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Don't let the great location fool you. You'd be better off taking your business elsewhere. We stayed for one night, and that night we weren't able to sleep until way past midnight due to extremely loud party music playing across the street. This was made worse by the fact that we had to catch an early ferry the next morning. While I admit the music is out of the hotel's control, the windows in our hotel room didn't close, meaning there was no way to shut out the extremely loud sounds. I don't think a room with permanently-open windows qualifies as a sleepable accommodation, especially with loud party music right next door. I contacted the hotel about a refund afterward, which I didn't receive because the manager said I didn't contact the front desk the night of my stay. My hazy, 2 am memory does recall trying to call, but it must have been a different number for the hotel because the manager didn't receive anything on her end. Either way, even if we had been re-located to a quieter room, having to change rooms in the middle of the night due to the first room being unsleepable would've anyway resulted in a 1-star review, so nothing short of a refund would really make me change my mind. All in all, avoid this place.
Read more
Date of stay: June 2022
Location
Service
Sleep Quality
Room Tip:If you're going to stay here, ask for the quietest side of the hotel.
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Response from Johan Z, Agency / Consultant at Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix
Responded Jun 30, 2022
Hello Leslie, Thank you for your review and welcome to the TA community as a new member with your first review! We are sorry to learn of your disappointment with your accommodations. Certainly if we would have received communication from you at some point of your one-night stay with us, we could have tried to find an amicable solution to any challenges if there were any. However we are pleased that you stayed with us and provided your feedback. Our prime location on the Christiansted Boardwalk makes it easy for guests to experience the best of St. Croix including restaurants and entertainment all steps from the hotel. We hope that you will come back to see us again to experience the warm island hospitality that so many folks have enjoyed over the years and that makes us a favorite choice on the island. All the best and be well!
Read more
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.
Book at your own risk! I feel like this place is a scam… My wife and I from Las Vegas booked a suite for our honeymoon with a King bed and couch. However the room we received is 2 double beds and 5 lounge chairs. This is not what we booked or expected. The room is filthy and looks like it hasnt been cleaned in years. There’s a boarded up window and exposed hole where the AC unit drains right over the bed. All furniture looks and feels dirty. The ceiling fans have inches of dust on them. We are not staying here not even one night, we don’t feel comfortable staying here. When we called the office about the bed mix up he said “I don’t know why this keeps happening”. The owner came by and said they couldn’t do anything until the next day and even then a room switch wasn’t guaranteed. For the amount of money they are asking it absolutely doesn’t add up. When we tried to notify the owner that we wouldn’t be staying and need to cancel and dispute, he started sending us straight to voicemail so we started a claim with Expedia to at least get the ball rolling. This was a devastating experience.
Read more
Date of stay: February 2022Trip type: Travelled as a couple
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
This review is written for a friend who is unable to write the review. This hotel apparently has fallen on hard times. My friend said that when arrived at the hotel. There was an note on the door advising her to call a number and they told her she can pick up the key from desk . The staff had gone home. She is physically challenged and she is on oxygen. The key to the room for a second floor room. There were no first floor rooms open for occupancy! The elevator was broken. She could not stay at the hotel. She tried days before arriving to contact someone to request a first floor room. She tried for days to get someone on the phone. No one picked up.
Please do not stay at this hotel unless you willing to take a chance.
Read more
Date of stay: September 2023
Value
Location
Service
Trip type: Travelled solo
Room Tip:Don't book this hotel
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
The advertisement didn’t match what I received. Between the bugs and just overall condition of the room, incredibly old and just had a dirty feel, it had me terrified. The room look like it hasn’t had a deep clean in years. The bed skirt was ripped, and so was under the couch. You could see the moisture on the ceiling and rust on the tub. You could also see super thick layers of dust and dirt between the bed frame and the table. There was no keeping or saving food because the little roaches came out immediately. I should’ve known something was wrong when I saw other people leaving early. I Did end up leaving early after seeing 3+ bugs in one sitting, this was after someone brought up raid and we sprayed the room. I felt fine upon arriving to the island/hotel, but immediately because congested and unable to breathe the longer I stayed in that room. As soon as I checked out and left I slowly started being able to breathe again. I absolutely won’t be returning or booking here again, I’ll spend the extra money and go to King Christian instead.
Read more
Date of stay: December 2022
Value
Location
Service
Trip type: Travelled solo
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Response from Johan Z, Agency / Consultant at Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix
Responded Dec 22, 2022
Dear Discover663116, We would like to thank you for taking the time to write a review. Upon further review I am not locating a reservation under your name "Discover663116", so can't specifically your review. We'd love to have to opportunity to learn more if indeed you were one of our valued guests. Please reach out to us with your reservation code so we can connect. We hope that we have the opportunity to see you again!
Read more
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.
The poor rating started first thing when we couldn’t even find the hotel or which door to use. There was a sign asking guests to call when they arrived but no one answers. Thankfully a local who owned the bar across the alley was able to get us in. Every single sound, including the exact words from the tv, could be heard from the room above us. I’ve never stayed anywhere, including old apartments from my college years, that allowed so much sound to travel to other rooms. The towels had yellow and brown stains on them. The TV barely worked, which was fine since we were out most of the time but we like to watch tv before bed. The pool was closed and only filled halfway with brown water—you’d think during high season they’d have their pool open. Two stars were given for the location.
Read more
Date of stay: February 2023Trip type: Travelled as a couple
Room Tip:Don’t stay here.
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Nice location and friendly front desk. After that it went down hill. While it's close to the water the windows don't keep out any noise as they don't close all the way. You hear the crowds from the boardwalk close by until late, then the roosters in the courtyard start crowing around 3:30 in the morning. So if you want to get some sleep, this is not the place. The room also needs lots of maintenance and TLC, is not very clean and just disappointing, especially for the cost, which is crazy high for the room you get. The morning breakfast is a basic as it gets and again, disappointing.
Read more
Date of stay: January 2020
Value
Location
Trip type: Travelled on business
Room Tip:Find somewhere else.
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
The room was very cozy and had a nice view. The ac worked well. I enjoyed a warm shower after exploring the island. The hotel had a beautiful antique vibe to it. The breakfast was not appetizing as it had flies but other than that the hotel has great accommodations. For the price you can beat it. I also enjoyed the soft bed sheets, the location and Peking is accessible easily across the street. You don’t have to pay additional for parking which is great. The hotel staff are amazing and very helpful they Evan gave me a after hours assistance. Anytime you need something they respond. The room was top quality.
Read more
Date of stay: June 2023
Value
Location
Service
Trip type: Travelled solo
Room Tip:The beaches nearby are great
This review is the subjective opinion of a Tripadvisor member and not of Tripadvisor LLC. Tripadvisor performs checks on reviews as part of our industry-leading trust & safety standards. Read our transparency report to learn more.
Response from Johan Z, Agency / Consultant at Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix
Responded Jul 1, 2023
Dear 312kikic, I am so pleased to know that you had such an enjoyable stay with us here at Club Comanche Hotel St. Croix. We love hearing that our valued staff provided personalized attention making your trip a memorable experience. I greatly appreciate you taking the time to post your comments and we look forward to welcoming you back soon!
Read more
Report response as inappropriate
This response is the subjective opinion of the management representative and not of Tripadvisor LLC.
We were there last fall and did not have any problems with bed bugs or construction. The early morning rooster crowing got a bit tiresome but that part of the deal when staying downtown.
Prices are the average nightly price provided by our partners and may not include all taxes and fees. Taxes and fees that are shown are estimates only. Please see our partners for more details.
Is This Your Tripadvisor Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
