We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
All reviewscookies and milkpopoversmartha's vineyardnewes from americasister propertychappy ferryhistoric hotelmiddle of townthird floorevery morningcorner roomno elevatorcontinental breakfastshops and restaurantslocation is excellentroom was largemain building
My sister and I stayed at the Kelley House for 2 nights and were very pleased with our experience. Nikki, the operations manager was fantastic! Always giving us good recommendations of things to do or places to eat. The hotel was small/moderate sized, with a...More
We stayed at the Kelley House in Edgartown on Martha's Vineyard in room 216. This hotel is as nice as it is charming. It is an old historic property with a few newer upgrades in room comforts but with a few classic amenities. For 1st...More
Service: A- (gotta control other guests better LOL)
Other Guests: B (so noisy & they were eating greasy food on the communal chess table - someone please say something to them!! >.<)
Food: free cookies & milk (8pm-9pm YASSS), muffins &...More
Staying in Edgartown was beginning to be a problem for us. For many many years we have just stayed at the Harbor View, but having had a horrible stay a few years ago we felt we didn't want to chance it again. So last year...More
Just spent three nights in room 206 of the main building while in town for a wedding. We had some concerns based on recent reviews, but found that the property seems to be in the middle of upgrading itself. We observed lots of new carpet...More
Response from jtnlawson | Reviewed this property |
After staying at the Kelley House over the New Year celebration I would ask them if they have updated there hot water issues as they ran out of hot water on the first day of our stay and then in the afternoon there was an... More
After staying at the Kelley House over the New Year celebration I would ask them if they have updated there hot water issues as they ran out of hot water on the first day of our stay and then in the afternoon there was an issue with the heat not working. The rooms are dated but more importantly the necessaty to maintain their hot water & HVAC systems is basic human need. The location of this hotel is wonderful as you know but I would question the updating of the very system that provide basic need.