We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
This historic property is well maintained with loads of ambience . A cordial and helpful staff compliment the experience. The rooms are quiet and furnished to enhance the historic feel of the facility . A lack of counter space in the bath creates a bit...More
If you're ever in Hamilton, NY, the Colgate Inn is an excellent place to stay, it is a little more expensive than some places in the surrounding area, but it is a super, very pleasing experience. Hamilton itself is very nice. It doesn't have a...More
Second time staying at the Inn but first time reviewing. Both stays were excellent. The ambience is always what I expect from an old Inn like the Colgate - warm cozy and professional. The rooms are lovely and comfortable and we loved the linens and...More
After a five hour delay at the airport and a challenge getting a rental car, we arrived at on a blustery and cold November evening to a warm and welcoming staff. Our room was a lovely, small, cozy pasteboard bed. The rooms are quaint and...More
I was finally able to get a room at the inn after 4 years of trying as it is usually sold out so I was excited. They should be embarrassed to charge what they do— $250 per night — for what you get. They are...More
2 Thank lspiegs
Response from Meghan L, Front Office Manager at Colgate InnResponded 30 November 2017
We apologize that your recent stay did not meet your expectations.
There are several routines our housekeeping and maintenance staff perform on a daily basis to insure proper cleanliness and maintenance. Our management team is taking this opportunity to talk with all departments property wide...More