We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Stayed by myself and felt extremely safe and comfortable. The rooms were very nice, staff service very accommodating. I think the gym needs an upgrade. The food service was quick and meals were delicious. Pool was well staffed with plenty of towels, umbrella set up...More
1 Thank Jean N
Response from MontaukMYC, Director of Sales at Montauk Yacht Club Resort & MarinaResponded 30 July 2015
JeanMelville - Thank you very much for your excellent review of MYC! We are pleased to share your comments with our entire team. Please plan to visit often, as we continue to add exciting events and activities, which I know you will enjoy! Chef Ron...More
When we booked our admiral class room the description was "overlooking the resort". The only thing our room overlooked was a hedge from floor to ceiling with peak-a-boo views to the parking lot. Be aware, if you don't pay for the courtyard or some kind...More
Response from MontaukMYC, Director of Sales at Montauk Yacht Club Resort & MarinaResponded 29 July 2015
billybob101 - Thank you for your comments. We greatly appreciate them and will share them with our managers and their teams. We hope to have the opportunity to welcome you back, as we are adding exciting new activities and events and new menu items for...More
This is a nice resort. A little way from the town/beach, where the main action is taking place (though they do offer a shuttle service). The Marina setting is very pleasant and relaxing.
I feel the rooms are over priced, though the whole of Montauk's...More
Response from MontaukMYC, Director of Sales at Montauk Yacht Club Resort & MarinaResponded 2 August 2015
Around_the_World - Thank you for your wonderful review and comments. We will review all with our managers and their teams, and share your accolades with Sandy. We continue to add exciting activities, programs and menu items for you to enjoy, which will all be posted...More
Given the prices you'd expect a lot more. For the experience we got (room quality, service, general feeling) I'd expect to pay 30% of what we actually paid. The view is the best thing about the hotel but nothing else is noteworthy at all.More
Review collected in partnership with this hotel
This business uses tools provided by TripAdvisor (or one of its official Review Collection Partners) to encourage and collect guest reviews, including this one.
Thank Gray H
Response from MontaukMYC, Director of Sales at Montauk Yacht Club Resort & MarinaResponded 23 July 2015
Gray H - We are sorry to hear that you did not enjoy your stay with us. If you do plan to visit again, I would like to reach out and understand more of what you would like better about your next visit. Best regards,...More
We loved the location of this hotel. Right by the water with all the gorgeous boats lined out back. They let us check into our room hours early which was a huge plus (just call ahead and ask).
Now for the hotel room, I have...More
Response from MontaukMYC, Director of Sales at Montauk Yacht Club Resort & MarinaResponded 20 July 2015
michellynn - Thank you very much for your nice review of MYC! We are thrilled you enjoyed your visit and will take your comments into consideration when discussing them with our team and managers. We are so proud of our new menu and exciting cuisine...More