Great food, service and charm galore. In heart of Sag Harbor and year round keeper. Thanksgiving and Christmas is totally awesome. Summertime crowd is over the top. Perfect for pre theater and special occasions. Lively bar scene as well
I used to adore the American Hotel restaurant, yes it was somewhat expensive but the food and atmosphere was worth it. Now it has crossed the line with entrees of close to $50. There is no excuse for this. The food is acceptable, and the wine list good, if you have money to…
Well-cooked food, white tablecloths, full bar, elegant service, wide array of choices, and delicious consistently : what’s not to love? No televisions blaring, cell phones must be silenced; lets just converse with our dinner partner! Old style supersedes.
No visit to Sag Harbour would be complete without a visit to the American Hotel, eat if you can - but booking is a must. Drinks at the bar will give you a sence of the traditional athmospher and you will be well looked after by Vinny.
This review is of the restaurant attached to this hotel. We were recommended this by a local for our first trip to Sag Harbour. We arrived very late for lunch but the staff were very good and we managed to have a terrific meal. Pretty standard offerings, but well prepared,…
"We were only here to eat, sorry!"
"This is a restaurant. Not sure they have accomodations"
"We just come for the food. We stay in the harbor on our boat."
"We ate in the restaurant. I have no idea what the rooms are like."
"Get a room facing the street."