Hotels near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)

THE 5 CLOSEST Hotels to Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)

Hotels near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)

Searching hundreds of travel sites to find you the best price

Sort by:

Best Value
Properties ranked using exclusive Tripadvisor data, including traveller ratings, confirmed availability from our partners, prices, booking popularity and location, as well as personal user preferences and recently viewed hotels.
Traveller Ranked
Highest rated hotels on Tripadvisor, based on traveller reviews.
Distance from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
See properties located closest to the place of interest first with confirmed availability for your dates from our partners.

Highest-rated 4-star hotel within 38 km of Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
Based on availability on Tripadvisor for March 30 - March 31
1. Pineapple Fields Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
592 reviews
Banks Road, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
37.8 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"The rooms, the decor, the setting, and most of all the owner, John, made this a perfect stay. His vehicles are the best I've ever rented on the island. Everything was on point! I'd never been to Twin Coves Beach..."
This is one of the most booked hotels in Eleuthera over the last 60 days.
2. La Bougainvillea
Enter dates to see prices
98 reviews
Banks Rd, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
36.0 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"Those are just 3 of words that come to mind! My (now) husband and I have been here twice. About a year and a half apart! The first time was just is, and we got engaged on one of the beaches just off the Mon-O-War..."
This is one of the highest rated properties in Eleuthera
3. Villa Allamanda, Eleuthera
Enter dates to see prices
210 reviews
Governor's Harbour Cigatoo Estates, Governor's Harbour 00000 Eleuthera
41.6 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"I first went to the island of Eleuthera following the painting trail of the great American painter Winslow Homer. I wanted to experience the unique quality of light that drew Homer to this paradise. I went the first..."
4. French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
274 reviews
Queen's Highway Governor's Harbour, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
39.7 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"I wanted to go back and write this review. My husband is lifetime titanium and they gave us an upgrade so we had two connecting rooms and a pool that was private for us. The resort provides a golf cart so you can..."
Visit hotel website

5. Squires Estate
Enter dates to see prices
98 reviews
Lignum Vitae Hill, 000 Eleuthera
39.3 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"Beautiful spot in Eleuthera!Comfortable and cozy and close to beautiful beach( walking distance) and restaurants too! Quiet neighborhood...we stayed in Mrs Russel's house that had a pool and beautiful outdoor space..."
Visit hotel website
6. Tropical Dreams Rentals
Enter dates to see prices
45 reviews
Queen's Hwy, North Palmetto Point Eleuthera
34.9 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"We stayed in one of the Garden Suites from February 8 to February 12, 2025, and had a wonderful experience in all respects. The resort has only 12 units spread over several acres with two separate swimming pools..."

7. Sky Beach Club
Enter dates to see prices
385 reviews
Queens Highway, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
43.4 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"We loved our stay at Sky beach club bungalow 1. Starting with the booking process, and communication. It was super simple. We had great communication with Pam and Eleuthera vacation rentals. The bungalow is large..."
8. Shannas Cove Resort
Enter dates to see prices
390 reviews
Shanna Bay, Orange Creek Cat Island
46.4 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"My wife and I stayed in Ellen’s Inn in June of 23’. We had a wonderful time on the island, and at the Inn. Mrs. Turnquest met us at the air port, took us in, and took great care of us. The rooms were cool and..."
9. Unique Village
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
102 reviews
Governor's Harbour, North Palmetto Point Eleuthera
35.1 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"This place is amazing! It is absolutely beautiful and quite stunning! The pics online don’t do it justice! It was very clean the rooms were perfectly appointed and the food and service was all so very excellent..."
This accommodation offers all inclusive options. Availability and additional pricing details can be found on our partner sites.
10. Orange Creek Inn
Enter dates to see prices
55 reviews
Queens Highway Orange Creek Cat Island
49.2 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"We stayed at Orange Creek Inn for nine nights. Pros – nice, helpful and responsive owners and staff, onsite grocery store and laundromat, very clean, AC worked well, hot shower, great value. Cons – Wifi ranged..."

11. The Historic Hilton's Haven
Enter dates to see prices
0 reviews
Thomas St, Tarpum Bay Eleuthera
13.5 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"We attempted to reserve the unit on Air B&B and received no response. We were in the area so stopped in only to find out from the owner that he no longer rents out on Air B & B and has a long term renter instead. He..."

No other properties match all your filters.

Clear all filters

or view Tripadvisor's suggestions below:

Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
This is the closest accommodation to Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
The Pilot House
Enter dates to see prices
Guesthouse
3 reviews
Meridian Highway, Rock Sound Eleuthera
6.7 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
#1 of 1 B&Bs / Inns in Rock Sound
"I booked Finiterre quite a few years ago. My husband I were so excited to have 12 days of paradise! The place was nice. Beautiful view. However my husbands father died unexpectedly which wasv truly devastating for..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Ingraham's Beach Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Inn
6 reviews
Queen's Highway, Tarpum Bay Eleuthera
13.5 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"What a lovely place to visit, wish we had stayed longer (instead of coming back to Nassau!). This venue (32 units I think) is privately owned but owners only have use of the facilities for 6 months of the year..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Cape Eleuthera Resort And Marina
Enter dates to see prices
Speciality Resort
94 reviews
Cape Eleuthera Boulevard, Freetown 26089 Eleuthera
18.8 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"My wife and I have been going to Pigeon Cay for a number of years. Leslie and Ned, owners and hosts, have treated us as family every time. The resort is paradise for those looking for peace and quiet, a fantastic..."
Visit hotel website
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Island Seaside Suites
Enter dates to see prices
Villa
4 reviews
Highcliff Drive, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
29.2 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"The new owners have brought Bahama Villa to the next level. Beautiful first class renovation!!! Thank you for your talent and hard work to transform Bahama Villa into a Ritz Carlton style gem . Top of..."

Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Bahama Villa
Enter dates to see prices
Villa
16 reviews
Ten Bay Eleuthera
29.4 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"My husband and I with our then 2 year old son stayed here a couple of years ago. The villa we stayed in which was supposed to be brand new was a dump. We were supposed to have satellite tv as the advertisement said..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Ellen's Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Bed and Breakfast
9 reviews
Queen's Highway Deadmans Cay Long Island
33.1 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"I dont have words to say - how COOL it was and how good! PERFECT! Openminded, friendly, nice owners who lives nearby in the next house, green beautiful territory with parking, green green grass, terrace, barbeque..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
The Barefoot Beach House
Enter dates to see prices
Ranch
23 reviews
Salate Drive South Palmetto Point Eleuthera
33.1 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"I found this wonderful place for my daughter to come and stay prior to joining a research project on the island. From the initial enquiry to leaving ,Karen has been outstanding. She knew my daughter was travelling..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Sir Charles Guest House
Enter dates to see prices
Lodge
1 review
Seaview Drive, South Palmetto Point Eleuthera
33.7 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"This small property on Seaview Drive in South Palmetto Point has three units. There are two 2 bedroom, 2 bath units and one 1 bedroom, 1 bath unit. It can handle up to ten people if you can book all together..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Eleuthera Retreat
Enter dates to see prices
Small Hotel
4 reviews
Banks Rd, North Palmetto Point Eleuthera
35.9 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"My husband and I went here for dinner since it's right down the road from where we are staying. We had the whole place to ourselves. Food was good but expensive. They have a nice bar but no drink menu. I wanted a..."

Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
The Potlatch Club Boutique Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Villa
2 reviews
Old Banks Road, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
37.9 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"What a magnificent spot. Located perfectly on the ocean with spectacular beaches and views far away from the rest of the world. It is a perfect place if you only want to rest and relax. We stayed in a two bedroom..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Finiterre
Enter dates to see prices
Ranch
5 reviews
Banks Road Eleuthera
38.1 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"Perfect location, excellent & attentive staff, fabulous food. Like having your own private island: boat available for use, walking trails, amazing beach with lounge chairs, games, beverage self-service. The Exumas..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
The Duck Inn
Enter dates to see prices
Speciality Inn
2 reviews
Queen's Highway, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
38.7 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"Exceptional location … accommodations are comfortable and clean. Steps from crystal clear beach. Felt like an infinity pool at our doorsteps. Main house made perfect gathering area for meals and family. Staff are..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Laughing Bird Apartments
Enter dates to see prices
Apartment
41 reviews
Governor's Harbour PO Box EL-25076 Eleuthera
38.8 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"We were a family of 5 staying for 5 days. Overall we were very satisfied with our stay in Island seaside suites. There are some 5 pointers and some 1 pointers in the location. The location is just perfect if you are..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Palmetto Shores Vacation Villas
Enter dates to see prices
Villa
3 reviews
Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
39.1 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"Tropical dreams rental is absolutely lovely, it is situated in North Palmetto Point, in the center of Eleuthera, so it's perfect to reach any part of the island with maximum 1 hour driving. The Hotel is owned by..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Mika's Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Guesthouse
21 reviews
3 Knowles Drive, Governor's Harbour Eleuthera
47.5 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"Mika is an amazing beach front boutique hotel situated on the Atlantic side of the island. The rooms have windows throughout to show see the beautiful views at all times including the sunrise right from your bed..."
Missing:ResortMotelHotelsAll Inclusive
Cocodimama Charming Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Small Hotel
13 reviews
Queen's Hwy, 11111 Eleuthera
48.5 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"This is certainly no Hilton, but if you want a bare-bones place to sleep and be almost on the beach, this is it. The room was much larger than most hotel rooms. The decor is outdated, but overall it was clean and..."
Missing:50 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
Pigeon Cay Beach Club
Enter dates to see prices
225 reviews
Pigeon Cay General Delivery to Arthurs Town Cat Island
63.3 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"The most fabulous place on earth!! Just my husband and I and a white beach! Couldn’t be more beautiful. Most incredible peaceful romantic holiday. Would go again in a heartbeat! Alexander is a great host. So..."
Visit hotel website
Missing:50 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
This is one of the most booked hotels in Eleuthera over the last 60 days.
The Cove Eleuthera
Enter dates to see prices
Resort
934 reviews
Queen's Highway, Gregory Town 1548 Eleuthera
73.9 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
"The Cove is like staying in paradise. We loved the one bedroom villa we stayed in with a beach view. Our friends stayed next door which was very convenient. We could sit in bed or on the deck and see the Caribbean..."
Missing:50 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
This accommodation offers all inclusive options. Availability and additional pricing details can be found on our partner sites.
Breakfast included
Fowl Cay Resort
Enter dates to see prices
Villa
177 reviews
Great Exuma
79.6 km from Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)
Visit hotel website

Showing results 1-30 of 30

Hotels Near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave) information

Hotels Near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)	There are 6 Hotels nearby in Rock Sound
Hotels nearby reviews	There are 9 reviews on Tripadvisor for Hotels nearby
Hotels nearby photos	There are 14 photos on Tripadvisor for Hotels nearby
Nearest accommodation	1.71 km

THE 5 CLOSEST Hotels to Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)

Hotels near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)

Property types

Amenities

Distance from

Traveller rating

Hotel class

Style

1. Pineapple Fields Resort

2. La Bougainvillea

3. Villa Allamanda, Eleuthera

4. French Leave Resort, Autograph Collection

5. Squires Estate

6. Tropical Dreams Rentals

7. Sky Beach Club

8. Shannas Cove Resort

9. Unique Village

10. Orange Creek Inn

11. The Historic Hilton's Haven

The Pilot House

Ingraham's Beach Inn

Cape Eleuthera Resort And Marina

Island Seaside Suites

Bahama Villa

Ellen's Inn

The Barefoot Beach House

Sir Charles Guest House

Eleuthera Retreat

The Potlatch Club Boutique Resort

Finiterre

The Duck Inn

Laughing Bird Apartments

Palmetto Shores Vacation Villas

Mika's Resort

Cocodimama Charming Resort

Pigeon Cay Beach Club

The Cove Eleuthera

Fowl Cay Resort

Hotels Near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave) information

Hotels Near Cathedral Cave (Spider Cave)

Hotels nearby reviews

Hotels nearby photos

Nearest accommodation