There are two must-visit restaurants in Playa Cocles (frankly, in Puerto Viejo and the entire Caribbean Costa Rican coast), Pecora Nera and this fine establishment very nearby. Both have their own distinct flair and identity. For fine dining and Italian/Tuscan food, journey to Pecora Nera....But don't push aside an opportunity to go to this incredible Argentinian steak house. This place served me the best top quality and seasoned and grilled New York Strip I have ever had. The owner and chef has carefully selected each cut of meat, and the care in selection, preparation, and grilling is immediately obvious even before you take your first slice with the knife. Accompanying the meat is the best in simplicity and flavor - a well-seasoned pile of french fries and a top selection of greens and veg comprising a great side salad, with oil and vinegar to dress it. My wife also had fries and a side salad accompanying her double bacon cheeseburger, as she said "the best burger she'd ever had." Absolutely no frills but the epitomy of top quality ingredients and preparation. To drink, she and I selected and shared a terrific bottle of Argentinian red wine.
In addition, the meal was prepared precisely as we requested - "medium" was exactly right on both accounts. The service was friendly and knowledgeable. The setting was near beachfront with calming nature sounds and quiet music filling the room. All of this for about $65, an absolute steal.
Pecora Nera has received some incredible reviews, but please, folks, do not overlook a visit here for dinner. This place could easily produce a Michelin star, and its simple charm, kind service, and reliance on high quality ingredients and preparation are the reason.More