Fish tacos great, service very friendly, pies are awesome. Highly recommend the Grape pie and Trius (3 fruit) pie. In fact they are so good that a friend asked us to pick up 3 they preordered and drive them 7 hours back to Montreal when...More

We took our friends to the Pie Plate so that they could enjoy it as much as we do. As usual, the pizza is the best. Thin crust with unusual toppings. This time I had the pear, prosciutto and gorgonzola variety. Of course we had...More

Quaint family business. Great atmosphere and wait staff. Minimal seating so get there early. Original cocktails. Loved the Rhubarb Negroni. On the recommendation of our waitress, I had the peach pizza. Absolutely phenomenal!!! Peaches, goat cheese, hot peppers, balsamic reduction and prosciutto. Very large portion....More

Love stopping in here every once in a while for pizza, salad or sandwich. Classic foods with a unique twist and fun menu. Relaxing atmosphere and also delicious baked goods! The pies are definitely worth their value.

I've eaten lunch here in the past, but prefer to come and pick up baked goods because the timing for meals (both seats and food) can be quite leisurely if they are busy. Pies and tarts are incredibly good and use local fruit. Many items...More

We stopped by on our way from Niagara on the Lake. The food selection was pretty standard- pizza, salad, meat pies...etc but the quality was top notch. The salad was very fresh and tasty. They also have a bakeshop but we arrived middle of the...More

My wife and I stopped for lunch. Food and service were really good. Friendly place that pays attention to what they put on the plate. They are also a bakery and if the scones are not sold out, you should try them.

We stopped here for lunch on a Saturday - had a ham/cheese grilled sammi, pizza, turkey/avacado sammi w. lime cilantro dressing. Nice blend of flavours for all of them. Strawberry lemonade was delicious too. Service was good. Stopped for dinner the next day. It wasn't...More

This place is quiet incredible. I have been stopping there for the last 6 years to get pies and in the last year or so they have set up a different door for take out and expanded the seating outside in what is a little...More

When we found our favorite lunch spot in NOTL closed for renovations, we took the short drive to Virgil to check out The Pie Plate as recommended by our B&B owner. It is located in a house with parking in the back. There is limited...More