Went to Gibby's on US Thanksgiving. Valet parking! Most places in Montreal in the Old Port in particular are iffy to find parking. Greeted and sat immediately. Our waitress was Caroline, outgoing, friendly and so helpful. Gibby's is a top of the line steakhouse. What...makes it so much more is value added. Most high end chop houses are all A la carte. At Gibby's you get a starter a potato as well as a vegetable!! Is the price high? Not really for all you get it is trully a bargain. The first thing you get is a loaf of hot bread and a dish of their homemade pickles. My wife started with a wedge salad, I had a bowl of Gazpacho. Both were cold and so good. Next Marion got the boneless Rib steak, I had the Beef Wellington. Each came with a baked potato as well as asparagus. Marion's steak was perfectly cooked and came with the restaurants version of Montreal Steak spice. My wellington was an 8 oz filet wrapped in duxellles and a delicious crust. The Wellington came with a perfect Bordelaise sauce. Both meals were delicious, tender, and an excellent portion size. For dessert we split an amazing dark chocolate mousse. Marion had a latte, but I opted for the Cafe Bresilian. This is Brandy, Tia Maria, Flambeed into a wine glass with a sugar rim, add coffee, fresh whipped cream, then ladled on flaming Gran Marnier. Caroline put on an amazing show and gave me a delicious end to a great meal. Do not look at the price and say too much. The food is great, the service amazing, and the value is excellent.More

This was a business dinner foo pop r 10 persons. I am told that a visit to Gibby’s steak and oyster is very much part of theMontreal visit experience and I can see why The service was outstanding from the moment we arrived We had...some oysters to start - fresh oyster and then a “Rockefeller oyster .. great thing to do The house salad was brilliant and the steaks were great - perhaps ever so slightly too well cooked for a medium rare but gorgeous never-the-less Too full for dessert but great choices Thoroughly repeat the recommendation we were given. If in Montreal I strongly recommend Gibbys in the heart of Old MontrealMore

Gibby’s is a long-standing restaurant in Montreal. We easily got a reservation (done online) and we’re seated right when we arrived. The menu is mostly steak and the steak sizes tend to be bigger. My 8 oz filet looked more like a 12 oz! Portions...of everything were very big, including side dishes and desserts. The service was very good - very professional staff. The ambiance is very traditional Old Montreal. Highly recommendMore

We have to say this place is one of the best places we have been to. It's just consistent, a great vibe, a great location of old Montreal. The food is outstanding. The service is very, very good. They know exactly when to come up...to you and see how you're doing and when to give you the space. You never have to wait for anything. They're funny. They've got big smiles on their face. We had our reservation. We were seated right away. The wine list is great. The menu is very diverse and everything looks tasty. And, of course, once you get it, it is. The prices are actually reasonable for what this place could be. It seems like the physical structure it's in is hundreds of years old, with all stone inside, several fire places, so it's super cozy. We went there on a Wednesday night, and it was very, very busy. Our waiter, Yvon, was excellent. We will definitely come back. This will be a staple for us every time we go to Montreal.More

Gibby's was a home run. The service is top notch, the food was absolutely delicious and the atmosphere is a totally classic steak house vibe in the heart of Montreal. Highly recommend the stuffed potato and Gibby's salad with your main. The petit filet was...plenty for me, it's huge!More

Probably the best steak I’ve ever had. Cocked perfectly and unbelievably tasty. The loaded baked potato was also delicious. Service was 5 star - shout out to Maurad!!!

Excellent food and drinks. Dining room was very attractive and food came out quickly and hot. Our server Cynthia was probably the best server I’ve come across in my 50+ years of dining out. Very professional, knowledgeable and super friendly. Can’t wait to go back...next time I’m in town.More

A memorable evening with friends in the most positive sense. Loved the setting, with exposed aged brick walls and beamed ceiling. Noise was reasonably dampened. But, as should be with a restaurant, the food and the service were the stars, and they were superb. Our...server, Vatchi, recommended a fantastic wine for our meal, was attentive but not intrusive, and he was willing to answer our questions and chat with us. We witnessed him perform an elaborate and impressive ritual preparing a Brazilian coffee.More

After walking out of Vieux- Montreal Steakhouse due to the unfriendly attitude and demeanor of the hostess we continued on and found Gibbys Steakhouse.Our experience was extraordinary! Greeted by upbeat smiling happy hostesses, seated immediately with our server Robin attentive although the restaurant was very...busy. The salad was excellent as were the perfectly cooked steaks and dessert drinks made tableside. Good food, and the friendly great service makes our dining experience 10 out of 10!More

Me and my wife had a wonderful dinner with friends this weekend. Totally recommend. A restaurant must try in montreal. Nice ambiance and food

Location great Service was awesome Steak were very good!!!! Rib eye melted Wine lovely Beer selection poor!!! Come on team

Had a delicious Rib eye steak, 22Oz. Service was outstanding, old town section, building and ambiance were great. Baked stuffed potatoes were really good, left very full