We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
Get food delivered

Ratings and reviews



US$30 - US$30
Italian, Mediterranean
Special Diets
Vegetarian Friendly, Vegan Options, Gluten Free Options
View all details
meals, features
Reviews (140)
Filter reviews
139 results
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year
Traveller rating
Show reviews that mention
All reviews tiramisu pasta veal chop scallops cake white wine special night cooked to perfection appetizers newburgh patrons
Selected filters
Updating list...
Reviewed October 12, 2021 via mobile

Service and food was amazing as always, clean safe and spacious, I had the fish special their yummy Tiramasu will be back for sure.

Date of visit: October 2021
Reviewed August 29, 2021

We went there for birthday celebration. When booked online, I marked down "birthday celebration" wishing sth special could be offered to the birthday person. I actually saw a cake with lighted candle was brought to the table beside us. However nothing was seemed to happen...to us. I asked the waiter if anything special for birthday person. He answered yes. Then the birthday person's desert turned free from the bill. No candles or anything else.. I felt they treated guests differently. Food there was okay. Service was okay. The important part I need to mention here is the desert. We ordered 2 Crème Brullee and sth else. I am a Creme Brullee lover and I order Crème Brullee wherever I go. When our Crème Brullees were brought up, I was shocked to see they were exactly the same as those sold in Costco. The only difference is it was only $10 each pack (12 cups) and I paid $10 each cup in the restaurant. A bit disappointed.More

Date of visit: August 2021
eusebio2015, Manager at Carmelina Italian Restaurant, responded to this reviewResponded September 1, 2021

Cynthia: We, at Carmelina's, want to apologize to you and your guests for the experience you recently encountered with us. We would like to assure you that we strive to provide our customers our best service. If there's anyway we can correct the situation and...More

Reviewed August 28, 2021 via mobile

Just had dinner at this awesome restaurant with my wife , the gentleman server was amazing , the food was also great , such a nice and friendly atmosphere, my wife and I enjoyed our night out, would definitely go back, thank you for the...lovely evening…….More

Date of visit: August 2021
Reviewed February 16, 2021 via mobile

Ordered take out tonight since COVID is still not allowing us to eat in. Best take out EVER. Usually take out doesn’t compare to eating in but their take out is just as wonderful as their eat in! Carmelina’s is always our go to when...we are in town monthly.More

Date of visit: February 2021
Reviewed December 9, 2020

Couldn't decide where to take my girlfriend for her Birthday but I remember having been to Carmelina Restaurant and totally enjoyed my night. I booked our special evening on Monday Dec 7th and it was a surprise to her as she has not been there...before. I did notice that the patio extension was done up very nicely and welcoming. Our server was very professional and attentive. His knowledge of the menu was spot on and recommended the best wine to go with which mains. We thought that it would be a great idea to share a few appetizers. Crispy calamari is my girlfriend's favourite. It was cooked to perfection ... crispy, hot and tender. Buratta is a fresh buffalo mozzarella served with ripe tomatoes, arugula, smoked salmon in a pesto olive oil .... YUMMY !!! We shared a portobello mushroom salad with goat cheese. These starters were fantastic and couldn't wait for our choice of mains to come. I had a mixed grill (I am a meat lover) of rack of lamb and veal chop. Medium rare is what I asked for and low and behold, it was done perfectly. My girlfriend ordered the seafood Newberg (a selection of shellfish). It had lobster tail, shrimps, scallops in a saffron white wine fish broth cream sauce. The seafood was done just right. Not dry, not overdone BUT fresh, juicy and tender .... PERFECT DISH ! Oh and by the way, the wines recommended with our meals were exemplary. This may sound like a lot of food but we made sure we had room for dessert. We shared a good portion of Carmelina's home-made tiramisu with Spanish Coffee. This was a VERY SPECIAL night (my girlfriend turned 28 .... I hope she doesn't kill me for revealing her age ... LOL). We will not hesitate to come back over and over as our night turned out to be absolutely and totally wonderful than we could have expected. I would DEFINITELY RECOMMEND this place. The patio looked magical with twinkling mini lights. We are seriously thinking of reserving Carmelina's for our Engagement Party in the Patio.More

Date of visit: December 2020
Reviewed September 8, 2020 via mobile

I had my 25th Wedding Anniversary party on September 5. Reserved a table for 11. Ordered from their Prix Fix Menu. We all had the Cream of Broccoli and Spinach Soup for appetizer. No disappointment. For our Entries, we had Linguine di Mare, Mushroom Risotto,...Veal Scalopinni, and Beef Tenderloin. All came in great portions and all tasted very good. The meals include two choices for dessert, Tiramisu or tartufu . Our party ordered both and both were good. Our server, Louie was very attentive and friendly. He had a picture taken with my wife and I. The only thing that stopped me from giving them a 5 is they had their front door opened and we had to deal with a fly.More

Date of visit: September 2020
Reviewed August 26, 2020

The good: The food is much better than I remember. The outside terrace is really nice and cozy with real plants. The bad: The waiter walks around with his cloth mask barely above his upper lip even when he's right on top of your table....The menus are not single use and are a bit dirty. There are runners on the table (Nice ambiance) but the exposed table is sticky. I didn't see anything being disinfected but they do have hand sanitizers when you leave. The food is good but they can do better to make patrons feel more comfortable during Covid!More

Date of visit: August 2020
Reviewed November 11, 2019

We enjoyed an early dinner here last week. The food was very good. Everyone enjoyed their meal. The portions were generous. The risottos were delicious. It was also greatly appreciated that allergies to certain foods was accommodated by the chef. The only drawback was the...limitation in the dessert menu. Gelato was offered but when asked all the restaurant had was gelato served as a chocolate raspberry tartufo. The tiramisu was a disappointment. It was soggy and definitely not worth the $9.00 price. The only other thing I wanted to point out is that on the website they offered a $40.00 prix fixe menu. This was not presented in the menu at the restaurant. Overall, it was a nice dining experience. The staff were very friendly. The atmosphere was nice. It was not perfect (i.e. dessert) but I would consider going back again in the future.More

Date of visit: November 2019
Reviewed November 1, 2019 via mobile

It was a seafood day. Our platters were full of what appeared to be a big assortment of seafood. But, after dissecting the selection, it turned out to have a lot of mussels and a few other selections. In the end all was okay

Date of visit: November 2019
Reviewed October 9, 2019

We had reason to have two meals in the last 1.5 weeks at the restaurant. Both were really excellent. The service was outstanding and so friendly. The food is really good. I especially like the risottos. The grilled calamari appetizer is so good. Decent selections...of wines at modest prices. We definitely keep coming back.More

Date of visit: October 2019
View more reviews
Best nearby
Best nearby hotelsSee all
TownePlace Suites Toronto Northeast / Markham
141 reviews
1.12 km away
Courtyard Toronto Northeast/Markham
258 reviews
1.12 km away
Hampton Inn & Suites by Hilton Toronto Markham
663 reviews
1.88 km away
Homewood Suites by Hilton Toronto-Markham
710 reviews
1.88 km away
Best nearby restaurantsSee all
Zen Japanese Restaurant
117 reviews
.32 km away
Mandarin Restaurant
241 reviews
.36 km away
Diana's Oyster Bar
110 reviews
.01 km away
Best nearby attractionsSee all
Pacific Mall Toronto
336 reviews
3.09 km away
York Cinemas
14 reviews
3.12 km away
56 reviews
.06 km away
Shopsy's Deli Markham
6 reviews
.76 km away
Questions & Answers
Ask a question
Maureen D
February 3, 2017|
AnswerShow all 2 answers
Response from Laura S | Reviewed this property |
Knowing the people that own this restaurant I am sure they would be happy to accommodate a child’s palate. I’d call ahead so that they can be prepared.
Is This Your Listing?
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.
Claim Your Free Listing
Frequently Asked Questions about Carmelina Italian Restaurant

Carmelina Italian Restaurant is rated accordingly in the following categories by Tripadvisor travellers:
  • Food: 4
  • Service: 4
  • Value: 4
  • Atmosphere: 4