Went for a birthday dinner on. Friday evening. Service was decent. Our waiter was pleasant. The food was mediocre and quite bland. I think the chef/cooks are trying to be too fancy with presentation that they are missing of taste and execution. You don’t need...to put micro greens on top of everything. I doubt we will return.More

Ordered the salmon and linguine the salmon tasted freezer burnt and my wife ordered the chicken parm there was more breading than there was chicken that's $250 I will never get back

Celebrated one of my best friend’s birthday here, my first time at this restaurant and it was fantastic! They service was very attentive and the food was absolutely delicious! Have told more of friends and work colleagues it is worth the drive to Whitby!!!!

We had a great experience with our most recent visit to Chatterpauls. We’ve been here a few times and have been generally impressed except for the last time. I don’t remember what the issue was at the time but we thought we would give it...another try and we are very glad we did. It was an excellent night. My partner had the curried mussels as a starter (they were very good) and the duck breast for a main. The fat came off easily and the duck tasted very good. I had the Coconut Shrimp as a starter (it too was very good) and the Steak and Shrimp as a main. My only disappointment was that the shrimp were not grilled enough. We also had a bottle of Mosole Pinot which was recommended and it too was excellent. Since it was our anniversary a complementary desert was offered and it too was excellent. And I had to try the carrot cake – worth the visit alone!! Overall the service was top notch – no complaints only praise. It was a little expensive but well worth it.More

Had an awesome dinner experience at Chatterpaul's. From our friendly waitress Jennifer who remembered our names and was on top of everything that our table needed. The Owner also was very friendly and sat with us for abit talking with us. Everything our table of...6 ordered was cooked to perfection, portions were plentiful and delicious 😋. We will definitely be back again.More

Came in for my birthday at 8pm yesterday… the server asked us if we were celebrating anything special and we had told her. She took very long at a table having a full out convo, when we were done eating. She stood at that table...talking for 15 min while we waited. The customer who she was talking to had to tell her to tend to us. She came over and didn’t apologize but giggled. We ordered dessert and it came but two tables down we heard her wish her a happy birthday. My fiancé thought she had something against us cause we were a younger couple? We usually tip 20% when we go to restaurants. It’s embarrassing to not. It was the first time he didn’t want to but he tipped anyway. Disappointed with the service but the food is 5 star. I’ve been before and I remember a five star service. Things change. She seemed to pick tables to be nice to and spend more time at. She didn’t pay any mind to us. Her tone was short. The only time she was quick to come to us was when the bill came. She thought we weren’t going to pay? That’s insulting.More

It’s been a few years since we’ve been back but it was the choice of friends who remember going there. We had enjoyed it before and last night was like old times.Everything was superb from start to finish.Nice drinks, tasty apps, special little nibbles from...the chef, excellent mains and great desserts. Our gentleman who served us was a real treat and coped well with our corny comments and had a few of his own. There was no rush and 3 hours passed very pleasantly. It was definitely the best choice for the 4 of us to converge from out of the immediate area. I mentioned that we were celebrating a birthday and an anniversary and another two plates of complimentary desserts arrived! Nothing but top notch from start to finish.More

The food and service were excellent. We went here for a special occasion and were very happy with our meal. We had baked brie to start and I had the rack of lamb. My wife had ribs. Both were delicious. My lamb was very tender...and tasty. The sauce was full of flavour. Our waitress was friendly and attentive. The one small criticism I have is a couple of the dishes have cranberries, such as the baked brie and the duck. I was going to try the duck but I'm not a big fan of cranberries. I'm sure they would have accommodated me if I asked. Overall, a very good meal and a good time. The restaurant is beautiful. The people we went with have several dietary restrictions and the restaurant is very accommodating.More

Our recent visit was Saturday October 30th, I left extremely disappointed and will never come back or recommend this place to anyone. In fact, I would go as far to encourage anyone who is considering dining here, rethink your plans! This was supposed to be...a bday dinner fore to celebrate with my wife and 2 daughters. I have ways enjoyed this place as we dined there many times before the pandemic and even ordered takeout during the pandemic in an effort to do our part and support local restaurants. So....indoor dining is back and we were geared up to have a great night and it was anything but. Hands down the worst experience at a restaurant specifically one that passes itself off as a fine dining establishment. I was shocked at how we were treated. Our server was not very attentive, and slow to a fault. It took her 15 mins to actually come to our table after we were seated when every other server was hustling and serving their tables. From the time we sat down it took 35 mins before we recieved water and ultimately the drinks we ordered. The restaurant was more than adequately staffed so speed and efficiency of service should not have been an issue. If that were the only issue of the evening I wouldn't have wasted my time in posting this review. Here's where things went sideways on what was supposed to be a joyous occasion. I ordered the Coco and Crab Cakes - which was one of my favourites from past experience. My appetizer was stone cold. So I flagged down our server and politely complained. She apologized and took it back to the kitchen. 15 mins later she brought back my app, it was the same one as I noticed the bite out of the crab cake, something was off. The sauce curdled and I noticed 2 pieces of pasta in the sauce which is not suppose to be there. When I originally received the dish it had a nice little chunk of lobster. So for $21 and do far a miss. I complained - again politely. Server argued with me told me it was lobster, I showed her and even tasted it and said to her it's pasta, like someone reused a saute pan and reheated my dish. 30 mins later 3 out if 4 of us finished their apps, I finally get mine back all freshly remade, the kitchen took it upon themselves to be creative and totally did a new sauce. No lobster dill cream, some over salted lemon cream sauce. To say the least I took 3 bites and didn't eat the rest. Enter the manager / owner Penny who came to our table - important to note that I never asked to speak to a manager. I thought the server had asked her to come and that she was comming to apologize and make things right. Well, right after she introduced herself she was on the defensive - didn't even allow me to speak basically shaming for the fact I wasn't happy that they screwed up my appetizer? Really? That's how you handle customer service? She then was more concerned with getting our entrees to the table when literally my appetizer had just arrived. She walked off and a minute later our entrees arrive. No apologies, nothing. I've never witnessed an owner acting like that. The funny thing is, as my wife and 2 daughters will confirm, I was nothing but polite the 2 times I complained about my appetizer. I was so shocked that someone would dare speak to a customer that is basically dropping over $300 on a Saturday night, like it's my privilege to eat there? Really? Every guest that dined there that evening it is a privilege for the restaurant not the guests. So in the end, the check arrives $318, the app that they screwed up three times was not removed from the bill, nor anything else. Most places would simply remove the item from the bill, apologize and maybe comp a drink or a dessert. Nothing was offered and I never asked. So as a result,as someone who spends quite a bit of money on dining at restaurants, this is one local spot that we won't be returning to. You had your opportunity to make things right and you chose to be arrogant and rude rather than listening to your guest. Zero customer service,questionable food handling practices. Avoid this place because if your experience is less than satisfactory and you rightfully complain, they will treat you like garbage and run off with your money! Experience does not match the dining check.More

Our first visit to Chatterpaul's was a complete success! The food was spectacular, the drinks were delightful, and the staff stellar. Even the COVID public health requirements were met in a thoughtful way, and were very much appreciated.

We had the Dinner for Two takeout special and it was fantastic. Looking forward to revisiting and trying other menu items

Great place for a good meal and good drinks with a fine dining experience and good atmosphere I highly recommend it.