We ate dinner here one night and found the food to be good however also found it to be a little overpriced for what you got. We had the Pickerel Dinner and the Fish Tacos. The server was very friendly and accommodating.

The service was fast and very friendly, but unfortunately that’s where it stopped. The Calamari appetizer was very sparse and the fish and chips were from frozen fish sticks. I was surprised when I asked the server if it was frozen, something she should have...told us before we ordered. Cole slaw came on the plate but it was warm because it came with warm food. It should have been served cold in a separate bowl.More

Great location. Great waitress, bartender.... the only one. Our waitress was the only one working.. And she had to tend bar. She was amazing and deserves 10 stars. Food... not so great.

Bay Street has a lovely atmosphere. The food is okay, the service is always nice and friendly! They make a mojito

It's nice to be able to eat outside in September and enjoy the good weather. As we were eating on the patio trains went over the Trestle Bridge three different times. It was nice to see. The cafe offers Trestle beer, made a short distant...away. The beer is good. I had the lasagna. I enjoyed it. Lots of cheese and a big portion. It came with rosemary flatbread. Very bland. Cod and chips were just okay. One long slender piece of fish, a bit overdone. Friends had pulled pork and crab cakes. They didn't say anything about it one way or the other so I guess it was fine. Service was good. We went in the late afternoon. It wasn't busy. I find this restaurant to be hit and miss. Sometimes good, sometimes not so good but the location is good with lots of parking and a nice view.More

We stopped for lunch on our way home from Callander, ON. My wife wanted a plain chicken sandwich and soup. Nope! You had to order the club house and have the lettuce, bacon and the third piece of bread removed. I ordered the pickerel on...a bun; it tasted a little fishy but I ate it anyway ---- bad idea. We ate here last year and it was terrific --- maybe they are burnt out after a long hot summer.More

Saw this place on trip advisor and thought we'd give it a try. Went for an early supper andnit was pretty quiet but by the time we left it was fairly busy. They do take reservations. Diner type setting and food. Caesars were delicious.

Not wanting a full meal, we came here to share a few appetizers and were not disappointed. The place was quite busy (usually a good indicator) and the prices and portion size quite reasonable.

Try the fish and chips with a local brew, you won't be disappointed. Make reservations as this is probably the busiest place near the dock. We often meet visiting boaters from the US. The dock is a short 150 yard walk away. Ask for a...terrace table with a view.More

Outdoor seating with water views. Had the lobster the first night-very good, and the fish and chips the second night-even better! The best I’ve had outside of NFLD. Deep-fried mars bar is to die for and the service is excellent.

A nice location across from the harbour is about all this place has going for it. The fish and chips were very poor. Cod should be fresh and flaky. Instead it was a mushy mush. The clam chowder was thick with flour and nowhere near...what a good chowder should be. However our server was very pleasant and efficient.More

We went back to the Bay Street Cafe when the food is still good. The salmon was good, The grilled trout was quite good. The veggies were only grilled zucchini, and the baked potato large but quite well cooked. We were able to get Trestle...lager but no other beers from the local brewery, This is a standard restuarant that hasn't changed to meet modern preferences for more and fresh vagetables beside the fish.More