Mussels, scallops, shrimp, rice, wine and half of lobster. Heat and serve. Single portion serves two for under $25. Add your own red wine and French bread. Transports me from the Jersey shore to Spain.
1 - 10 of 33 reviews
Terrific seafood market. Very fresh. Busy but they work quickly to move people. They also have some prepared items, the stuffed scallops are fantastic. They also prepare items for takeout. Always good Tried coconut shrimp today and it was the best I ever had, tender...More
Staying in the area a must go. Need fresh fish you need to stop here. Owner really nice guy, definitely helps with the selections. All the workers are great. If you want to have an ultimate seafood bbq you have to stop in. Has a...More
We ordered clam chowder, lobster bisque, clam strips, coconut shrimp, fried talipia, calamari and several different combination platters. All were "ok" but nothing special. We called ahead and were told 25 minutes but in reality it was closer to 40 minutes.
First of all this is a fish market and not a restaurant but they do prepare dinners and sandwiches to take home. Ortley Fish Market consistently has really fresh seafood. We have a vacation home about a mile away and I usually stop here at...More
Very enjoyable, Ortley institution. Glad that they survived Hurricane Sandy and the subsequent economic nightmare. Great fresh fish. Enjoy!