BROTHERHOOD OF THIEVES, Nantucket

We always hit up the Brotherhood everytime we're on the island, but were disappointed this time. Service was slow and not the best. Food was average at best. We were seated upstairs, which isn't our favorite and this time seemed like they were just stashing...people up there as overflow. We've had much better food here, and is always a standby, so just chalking it up to a bad day.More

Date of visit: July 2020

Helpful?2

truthintravel60763

170 reviews

Reviewed September 13, 2020 via mobile

DONT SKIP THE......

Don’t skip the peanut butter and jelly pie. Ummm In addition the drinks were amazing. I am always a red wine drinker but they talked me into a drink and even invented one based on our likes and it was awesome. We liked it so...much we went there twice for a midday lunch and drinks. Also the lobster bisque is second to noneMore

Date of visit: September 2020

Helpful?1

Rick L

4 reviews

Reviewed September 11, 2020

Wonderful

Short and sweet.....this great spot. Service is friendly and efficient, food and drink are delicious. The crab cake sliders were some of the best crab cakes I've ever had and the bushwhackers rivaled those I've had in the Caribbean. Add Brotherhood to the list when...you visit ACK.More

Date of visit: August 2020

Helpful?

Travel0116

73 reviews

Reviewed September 8, 2020

Great place for lunch

My family and I had a great relaxed lunch here. The clam chowder was delicious and so were the burgers, but the lobster bisque with the flaky crust was really something special. They don't take reservations, but we didn't have a problem getting a seat....We'll definitely be back again!More

Date of visit: August 2020

Helpful?1

511jerseygirl1965

56 reviews

Reviewed August 29, 2020 via mobile

Good for a drink & some apps

This worked for us for a quick drink and a bite to eat while shopping in the area. Burger & fries were excellent! It’s a dark tavern kind of atmosphere though, so if you are looking for ambience, keep that in mind! Highly recommend the...crab cake appetizerMore

Date of visit: August 2020

Helpful?

835mariea

45 reviews

Reviewed August 23, 2020 via mobile

This Restaurant Always Hits the Spot

Great service, casual atmosphere and some great dishes for lunch or dinner. Highly recommend the crab cake sandwich or sliders and the lobster bisque!

Date of visit: August 2020

Helpful?1

homebody12

59 reviews

Reviewed August 17, 2020

Love this old place, but the food has gotten pretty bad. Meanwhile you still pay Nantucket prices. I had some kind of seafood newburge thing that was barely cooked. Surprised I didnt get sick

Date of visit: August 2020

Helpful?2

FrancineN214

264 reviews

Reviewed August 10, 2020

Outstanding

While on Nantucket for a day, we tried the highly recommended Brotherhood of Thieves. For those that want a water view, this is not - it’s in town, a little off the beaten track. But, if you’re looking for excellent food and service, this is...your place. The shrimp were huge, perfectly cooked and the cocktail sauce had enough of a kick without making your eyes water. We went for their signature dish of 35 years - the lobster bisque that was topped with a light flaky, pie crust. It was outstanding. Service and food were top notch. Kudos to our server - she never missed a beatMore

Date of visit: August 2020

Helpful?2

greatbigsoxfan

85 reviews

Reviewed July 16, 2020 via mobile

Still outstanding after all these years

Have been coming here since the mid-70s and have never been disappointed Service is prompt and friendly, food is reliably excellent.

Date of visit: July 2020

Helpful?

View more reviews

Previous Next