It was an amazing to see the surroundings was so beautiful which makes me to stay there and having enjoyment there for alot of tine
1 - 10 of 1,091 reviews
Excellent clam chowder and lobster rolls. Pleasant atmosphere and great service. It is always a plus when someone besides your server checks on you
We ate here twice during our stay! Not the best, but not the worst place! The items I got where alright, but I think you might find better place to eat. A little pricy for what you are getting!!! Just wasn’t a fan!!!
We had dinner here on a Wednesday night. The atmosphere of the place is great. Service was excellent. Menu choices were good. Food tasted good. But final bill was very high.
We have enjoyed the Brotherhood for years! Each year something is different, but even better! Great drinks! Try the “Bamboozle”! The Clam Chowder is the best!
You expect a little rapport with bar staff. Unfortunately not here last week Bar man served efficiently. But not the most friendliest. In fact it was our first night in Nantucket and the reception ensured that we did not return
I think this is a great place to stop off at for some drinks before going to eat. it is in the basement of a house and has a cool vibe going for it. Food wise it was like pretty much any sports bar type...More
Sit outside if possible-it’s a lovely place to people watch and the food is great! The prices are reasonable for the island as well. Staff was friendly and helpful.
Dinner experience that brings happiness to our cravings with our favorite food they always served great consistently and nice staff too.
We had 9 of us out to dinner on Nantucket and had heard great things about Brotherhood of thieves. Service was spot on! We almost had our own room. Something for everyone on the menu. Chowder was amazing. Huge salads. Hot perfectly cooked scallops. Kids...More