Worst pizza in the area. Not enough sauce, very doughy, sparse toppings. Drive a little further to Fierro's in East Hampton or Sausages in Montauk.
1 - 10 of 39 reviews
Although they do serve more than just pizza and hero sandwiches.. that's all I've had there. The pizza is average; will satisfy when you're in the mood for pizza. The hero sandwiches are not as satisfying. I've tried several ones, prepared even without the sauce...More
Excellent pizza and calzone-made to order along with pasta dishes, gorgonzola or Greek salad. Fast service, reasonably priced-great for take out or eating in
I live about 20 minutes away from Astros pizza, but it is the best tasting pizza around. Once a week we order pizza to pick up. Usually it is their "light pizza" which is fresh tomatoes, fresh mozzarella and a basil pesto or their regular...More
I happened opon this gem with my family on our way home from Montauk. The food is out of this world. Great service. I will make a point of going there any time we can.