Be sure to make a reservation in advance so you can this whimsical place. When we went the chef offered one complete meal. It was superb.
11 - 20 of 176 reviews
My sister traveled to Contadora 2 years ago first describing of this 'gem'. On our Panama vacation, met a woman who is a resident at Contadora and she echoed the praise. Sunday was the first day on the Island, and hearing they would be open...More
No menu... no prices.... everything is fresh and it was very good with an romantic night time setting. The Italian chef/owner creates a wonderful meal. He even gave us a ride back to our hotel. It was just way too expensive.
It is not open every day, so check..food is good and owners service oriented and smiling. It has a variety of food to chose, but pizza was good.
The most friendly team around, great food and quite reasonable pricing. We stayed on Contadora for 5 days and this is by far the best place for dinner than the rest on the island. Really delicious menu offering different dishes every day
This was our third time back to Isla Contadora, and Casa Tortuga continues to be the best spot to eat on the island!
We had been told that this restaurant did excellent food but was pricey. The restricted choice of dish of the day or pizza is fine but it really would have benefitted from a priced menu - as a blackboard maybe - to confirm the cost....More
My husband and I enjoyed our best meal on Contadora at Casa Tortuga. The setting is eclectic and cozy. There is no menu so the choice is pizza or chefs dish of the night. It includes a delicious salad and dessert and everything was very...More