Locally sourced and lovingly prepared, we were thrilled with the entire experience. The servers are absolutely professional, clearly having 5 star backgrounds. Everything is made fresh... I mean everything. I had the best thousand island dressing ever; and my husband, from Boston area, had the...More

Visited homer from the Uk, 6 off us and we ate here on 3 occasions over the coarse of 6 nights, wonderful!! Very friendly staff, good food & warm atmosphere, definitely like to visit again if ever back in Homer. 5*****

I go to Homer once a month and always stop for dinner here. I've always had an excellent meal (haven't tried the pizza yet but I hear it's wonderful) and the service is great, always a friendly greeting and very attentive. I'd like to try...More

We stopped for lunch after picking up the rental and it was so good we came back for dinner. I had the Ruben sandwich and it was as good as any I've had. For dinner I had chicken Alfredo and again was delicious.

My Dad wanted pizza and he had eaten here before. He's very conservative when it comes to eating and because he had eaten here in the past he felt comfortable coming back here. When we arrived here there was a bit of a wait. We...More

I can’t get over this amazing place! Excellent service, incredible food! I had the roasted cauliflower wrap, my hubby had the ribeye and kiddos had the cheese pizza. How do they make a simple house salad taste so good? DO NOT MISS THIS PLACE!!!

My husband was stuck in Anchorage, so I had dinner alone at Fat Olive’s. The server and hostess were both friendly and took good care of me, knowing I was upset at being alone. I treated myself to this amazing cake. They had me at...More

This is our second time to Homer and our second time at Fat Olives. We decided to get a take out pizza as we were travelling for a sports event and cramped for time. We ordered their large 28 inch pizza. It was huge and...More

We stopped here for a dinner with a group that had a wide variety of tastes. Fat Olives met all of those requests! The food was very tasty! The service was great. The only heads up is that the calzone takes 20 minutes (or longer)....More

Friendly atmosphere. Waitstaff very helpful. I had the "ABC" Sandwich with a cup of soup. Both were awesome. Never would have thought apples would go so well on a sandwich.