Our family went on a Friday evening over to The Colony Inn and Cafe. We had three different orders: a ribeye, a New York steak and the seafood bucket. All of them were quite tasty; everyone was pleased; and we would repeat the visit.
1 - 10 of 57 reviews
We go here for lunch often and the owners are friendly and serve great sandwiches, soup and salad. Several groups gather here on a day of the week so it is a great way to see friends you don't see everyday. The food is served...More
Husband orders petite rib eye every time. I order many different things. Battered shrimp, Seafood bucket, Hamburger with avocado & bacon, Salads and Prime Rib Philly. Friday Calm Chowder is thick and delightful best in Palmer.
We ordered the Ribeye steak and for the price we were insulted by being served a gristly flat iron. We know our cuts of meat and this was very disappointing.
I can't go on enough about this marvelous place. I had my engagement dinner here. It was the best. We got a private dining room. And the food was awesome. All the tables and chairs were real birch and at least 50yrs old. All preserved...More
I enjoyed the homey feel...the service was great. Staff warm and attentive. My cheeseburger was disappointing. The meat had firm pieces of something...not sure....the lettuce was chopped and squished in mayo to hold it all together..Would prefer a lettuce leaf or 2.....Didn't really care for...More
I have eaten before and enjoyed it thoroughly, I came back and loved it even more! I came on a Sunday afternoon at about 2:00 pm. I tried every dish in my party and -wow!- they were fantastic. I wouldn't recommend getting a burger (the...More
The bucket of shellfish (I forgot what it's called) was fantastic. Generous amount of mussels, clams, crab legs, potatoes, and corn. The servers were very helpful as well. Only good things to say about this place.
I've been to this lovely historic restaurant several times and ordered several different dishes. Everything I've ever had has been delicious. Beautiful presentation of the food, great service, and cozy setting. We love this place!
The shrimp were big and plump and very fresh. the batter light and sealed in the sweet flavor of the shrimp. clam pasta was light and flavorful. a little expensive but quality food and server was friendly and efficientt..