Great atmosphere Great employees Average pizza Enjoyed it but have had better(: The pizza is not as great as everyone says it is but it is a nice place. The pizza slices are a good size.
1 - 10 of 55 reviews
Just stopping in for a slice I found that the maxed out veggie slice I had was very good but not quite warmed up enough off the table. They have a gluten free crust for those interested. Otherwise just a pretty good California pizza parlor
Was looking forward to late night pizza and the pies looked good in the case, but they turned out to be cardboard-like and lacking flavor. Also, not exactly cheap.
Don't know about the full pizzas, but the slices are pretty bad. They have them premade but not cooked and throw them in the oven. They get brown on the bottom, but aren't completely cooked. A tomato came off mine and I could see how...More
i had the pepperoni slices and they were really tasty. It would have been nice if they were less oily but its not pizza if its not greasy ;). Though my two slice costed almost papa johns large one topping pizza but taste was really...More
Whether we're in Capitola, Santa Cruz, Mountain View or Palo Alto (our most recent visit), we'll often stop by Pizza My Heart for a slice of great pie! A touch of New York's finest in California - the best of both worlds! They have a...More
I have to say I'm surprised to see more 4 stars than 5 for this place. Their pizza is really great. The crust is great, their combinations are very well paired and the quality is also excellent. If you're looking for a slice you really...More