Not sure we will go there again. Very good pizza but the service was very, very slow. Do not go during peak times as it will take a very long time to get your food.
1 - 10 of 59 reviews
When Gatsby's was good - it was great thin crust crispy pizza. As time went on there was no consistency in quality. Sure, good pizza in FL is over priced compared to our suburban Chicago area but it was good with "real" sausage. We had...More
Best pizza! Right from Gahanna (Columbus), Ohio! Go Buckeyes!!!!!! Pizza cut in squares not wedges, so much easier to eat because Buckeyes knows best! O-H-I-O. Greg, the owner is always around to greet his guests with a smile and sometimes even with a song, even...More
I was on a trip to visit my mom in Bonita Springs. We wanted to grab some pizza and found Gatsbys. What a terrible choice. The music was outdated and way too loud, the pizza was mediocre, and there were no options for different pizzas...More
In on Friday night and sat at the small bar. My wife per the menu chose Moscato wine. Didn't have! Then asked for white Zinfandel...didn't have! Finally opted for Chardonnay! Place was empty on a Friday night. When departed a mere 6 patrons in the...More
food was awful, no more needs to be said. The owners were very nice, we wanted to tell them how bad the pizza was, how awful the sauce was, but we didn't have the heart to tell them the truth. We paid, left, and will...More
We are all about second chances, but never again will we go here. Last Friday went later in evening. Took a bit to get seated. Not a lot of smaller tables and place is poorly laid out. Waitress, Calinda, got our drinks pretty fast, but...More
Called in a pizza about an hour ago, I just picked up the sausage banana pepper pizza and am flabergastered. It's barely a 12 inch pizza with about 1/2 cup sauce 10 crumbled pieces of sausage and a few banana peppers. Loads of air pockets...More
Visited twice on Friday evenings, for our pizza fix, which is significant, because on both occasions the constant phone orders created a chaotic situation for the otherwise genteel bar keep. We sat at the bar both times and witnessed orders being jumbled and even in...More
This is an excellent place for pizza. The owner was present and made rounds to assure your satisfaction. One of the best pizza places in SW Florida.