The best I have ever had!!! After walking the beach and not wanting to dress for dinner we stopped here. The best choice ever!!!
1 - 10 of 25 reviews
We are regular visitors to Captiva. And generally we've learned that you go to the restaurants on Andy Rosse not for the "best meal of your life" or the "best bargain", but rather for the convenience or the experience. We picked up a couple of...More
We ordered a large pizza, which was GINORMOUS! It was the island favorite and it had plenty of toppings and was delicious. The wait to get our order delivered was about 90 minutes. The delivery driver complained in the background on the phone that they...More
Great pizza -- just like New York. Loved the crust and sauce. We have it each time we visit Captiva. Now, if only they would deliver!
It looks like pizza, but it doesn't taste like it. The cheese was nicely melted, but it didn't taste like mozzarella. The crust was browned on the bottom, but mushy throughout. Reminded me of a frozen pizza heated up in a microwave oven. You pay...More
We live on Captiva, and had not tried Captiva Pizza in several years. Called in an order and went to pick it up. The place is pretty dumpy looking. Pizza was ready when I arrived. I asked if they still delivered. The guy said yes,...More
We offer delivery on Friday and Saturday nights, our location is small take-out pizzeria, we are not a fine dinning establishment, nor do we advertise that we are. Many families love the affordability and convenience of our pizzeria. I hope readers take into account the...More
Checked in to Southseas plantation and didn't want to go out. Reached out to Captiva PIzza, we had two pizzas and salad. The pizzas where delivered as promised, they where hot and sauce had great flavor. Would have preferred a thin crust but overall the...More
Thank you very much very taking the time to review our pizzeria, we appreciate your kind words, and it was a pleasure delivering 3 more pizzas couple days later. Hope you and your family had great vacation at South Seas and hope to see you...More
To my knowledge this is the only pizzeria on Captiva. My family thought the pizza was satisfying but the menu is limited. OK for take out to solve your pizza craving, Reasonably thick and filling, but average in taste and out of site in price....More
Thank you for taking the time to write a review of our Pizzeria. Hope you enjoyed your vacation. Pizza and salad is a great alternative on Captiva Island, there are many fine restaurants on Captiva Island, but we can provide a nice meal to take...More
We ordered 8 pizzas for our family reunion. Different types, Cannonball, all veggie, plain cheese, pepperoni, and one with no cheese. They were all perfect! Excellent crust, numerous toppings and very consistent.
Thank you for your kind review! Pleasure serving such a great occasion! God Bless. :-)
very expensive for pizza, hard to get to (upstairs), good flavor but nothing to write home about. Wish they would deliver for the price
Thank you for your business, we deliver Friday and Saturday nights!