It's a gas station with a pantry and pizza place attached. It's nice inside, very busy, easy in and out. The pizza place they have is good as well. Got the 20' we could not finish it was so big. I would def. order again.
91 - 100 of 314 reviews
Pizzeria has old world charm with New York Style Pizza in brick oven. Great personal service. Pizza was best I have tasted.
Picked this up on a bill board going into St. Augustine. Staff was so friendly and the pizza and fresh salad were the best. Our portions were so large, we took home and it was just as good warmed in the oven later. Hope to...More
If you are in St Augustine you must try this place we decided to try this place on March 19th the food and the service was fantastic both me and another family member ordered the two slices of cheese pizza which was a special the...More
I will not eat pizza anywhere else. Not only is the pizza great, but the people are so friendly, we feel like family! Bonus, it is affordable!
We only had 45min before our concert started at the Presbyterian Church around the corner from Carmelo's. We were seated within 10 minutes, we were greeted by the owner after sitting down and ensured we would be in and out. We were treated like family,...More
We had a great pizza. The pizza had a thin crust with plenty of toppings. The waitress was very accommodating. She even gave us directions for returning to our hotel.
We rate their pizza in the top 5 in St Augustine. Fast pizza with a friendly staff. Buy a fresh pizza and skip the slices...although they are very good if your in a hurry. Great prices for great fast food.
The driver on our Red Train tour pointed out Carmelo's to us and mentioned how great the pizza was. I doubt we would have ever found this place on our own. The pizza was excellent. We would definitely go there again.