We stopped in for a quick lunch, not disappointed. Shared pizza, salad and a pasta dish. Delish. We all agreed we would return. Service was as good as the food.
1 - 10 of 30 reviews
Ive been to Papa's (as we call it) many times...always good. You can clearly see and taste the care in the food. Meatballs are crazy good. Try the chicken Parm sub! Pablo is friendly and always accommodating to any menu change (if you have picky...More
We had been past Papa Giorgio's many times and never gone in. We decided to try it one night and were blown away. I ordered a lasagna. It came with a delightful fresh salad and delicious home made bread. So far so good. Then came...More
We came in here for dinner one night and decided to try the eggplant parmigiana. When we asked the waitress how it was, she said we sell a lot of it. That should have been a warning for us - just because they sell a...More
We visited while vacationing and found the place to be small and crowded. The gluten free pizza was not the best and the waitress did not put the order in as it was given, so the pizza did not come as ordered. They were out...More
the staff is so incredible and sweet, competent and fast. the pizza is the best; the thing that makes it the best is the homemade pizza sauce, which I could drink for breakfast, lunch, and dinner. It's really that good! The spaghetti and meatballs are...More
I can only speak for the pizza, and would recommend ordering pizza at one of the may good pizza joints in Sarasota. They charged $2.50 for 8 pieces of anchovies. I guess that's one anchovy per slice. If I was the owner, I would re-think...More
We usually go for dinner but we both were in the need of a Papa G fix, so we headed over for lunch. Don't let the exterior deter you from trying this place. Fresh pasta, delicious sauces, wonderful house or Caesar salad and home made...More
Love this place! Try to eat there once a week. Great food, service, atmosphere and people. The meatballs, pasta, chicken, hot bread right out of the oven, pizza, Italian beer......all of it.
It always amazes me how some of the best places to eat are the ones that are buried in the corners of some strip mall. Papa Giorgio's is no exception. And once you walk through the door, you can relax and kick back with "family."...More