We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.
We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

The Old Mill Restaurant

5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, IN 47720-1746
+1 812-963-6000
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
  • Excellent13%
  • Very good13%
  • Average8%
  • Poor13%
  • Terrible52%
16 Apr 2017
“Never again ”
6 Mar 2017
“This place should be reported to health department”
Open Now
All hours
$$ - $$$
5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, IN 47720-1746
Write a Review
Reviews (23)
Traveller rating
Traveller type
Time of year

1 - 10 of 23 reviews

Reviewed 16 April 2017 via mobile

I have to say ranks as my worst almost dining experience ever. Made reservations for Buffet remembered this place from many years ago, upon entry the smell almost knocked me out. Nasty, dirty, dark, disgusting atmosphere, food looked like it had sat out for hours....More

Thank T P
Reviewed 6 March 2017 via mobile

Do not go to this restaurant dirty dark and has a bad smell . Worst Buffet I've ever seen in my life, the food was sometimes warm sometimes cold. you couldn't hardly see what you were getting and service was terrible if I could do...More

1  Thank robby c
Reviewed 21 June 2016

fathers day we choice the mill for a family gathering for some great fried chicken with all the fixins food was great but the mill was a step back in history definately not a cookie cutter.Cindy our waitress was super friendly as was all the...More

Thank rexj5
Reviewed 20 April 2016

At 6 pm, only one other table had customers (they waited even longer) which should have warned us to leave then. Atmosphere: dingy. Cleanliness: awful. Service: terrible. Food: even worse. We waited almost an hour for food that was tasteless and cheap.

1  Thank Rggzz
Reviewed 28 September 2015

There were 120 of us and reservations were for 90. The staff was great in adapting to the our needs. All linen table cloths and napkins The buffet was fresh, plentiful and tasty. And the price was reasonable!

2  Thank Barney1943
Reviewed 19 August 2015 via mobile

So we drive three hours to check this place out for having a rehearsal dinner. Didn't even want to get out of the car, but we were meeting other people there. And they were already inside. Horrible, and dirty, and people were actually eating there!...More

3  Thank tfc63
Reviewed 9 August 2015 via mobile

Been here a number of times. It's quaint. Built in an old building. Inconvenient if you have party members with special needs. Food is nothing special. The Amish place near the turn is better.

1  Thank indyizzi
Reviewed 17 May 2015 via mobile

I had lunch here with my family today and it was actually pretty good. This is one of my Grandmother's favorite places, and as we were in town for a visit, it was her choice. The atmosphere is very dark and dingy for sure, but...More

Thank JBrackett-Nashville
Reviewed 20 November 2014

My wife and I recently dined at The Old Mill, along with her parents. I have eaten there 3 or 4 times before. The first time was a great experience. The second time a little less great. The third time not great at all. And...More

1  Thank GBUNT
Reviewed 22 September 2014

This restaurant is HORRIBLE. Just a few years ago it was decent & used to have a nice family atmosphere. Now they seem to be cutting corners wherever they can, from decreasing the buffet offerings, to cutting down on utensils like crab crackers, to offering...More

Thank cmarino1
Nearby Restaurants
Hilltop Inn
82 reviews
3.79 km away
Los Bravos
66 reviews
4.41 km away
Spankeys Una Pizza
14 reviews
4.29 km away
El Charro Mexican Restaurant
17 reviews
4.38 km away
Nearby Attractions
Dream Car Museum
127 reviews
6.78 km away
Bosse Field
95 reviews
6.92 km away
Mesker Park Zoo & Botanic Garden
313 reviews
3.48 km away
Willard Library
59 reviews
6.87 km away
Questions & Answers
Get quick answers from The Old Mill Restaurant staff and past visitors.
Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page.
Posting guidelines
Improve this listing

Restaurant Details

Rating summary
  • Food
  • Value
Lunch, Dinner
Restaurant features
Reservations, Seating, Waitstaff
Open Hours
11:00 - 19:00
16:00 - 20:00
16:00 - 20:00
16:00 - 20:00
16:00 - 20:00
Location and Contact Information
  • Address: 5031 New Harmony Rd, Evansville, IN 47720-1746
  • Location: United States  >  Indiana (IN)  >  Evansville
  • Phone Number: +1 812-963-6000
  • E-mail