I have been coming here for years. The food is good. My favorites are the halibut Oscar and the shrimp in a net. I miss the pickles in a crock on the tables.
1 - 10 of 403 reviews
This was formerly a great town favorite for seafood, but after an ownership change and ensuing employee changes the service and quality of food has suffered greatly. Slow, non-caring service and less than top-notch food is the now norm.
Another great restaurant in downtown Madison where the seafood is always prepared correctly, unlimited salad bar, and desserts to make everyone full by the time they leave this restaurant.
Great little place for seafood and dining. They treated my niece like a princess so she totally enjoyed it. She doesn’t like fried shrimp; they fixed her grilled shrimp. It was decorated well for Christmas and very friendly staff.
The seafood was fresh and well prepared. We had the seafood Norfolk, the shrimp and scallops were both cooked just right. Family restaurant, friendly service, clean with a hometown feel. We visited at night so we were not able to appreciate the river view. First...More
We were looking for a nice dinner while visiting Hanover College. Key West Shrimp Company is in the Madison Historic District and has an old fashioned steak and seafood house atmosphere just across the road from the Ohio River. Steaks and salmon were good. Service...More
We loved the atmosphere and the food. The lady that greeted us at the door was very warm and welcoming even though it was 20 minutes before closing time. (We did not realize they closed during the day.) Our waitress was wonderful as well. I...More
My husband and I really enjoyed our seafood. The service was very good as well. This place is obviously loved by the locals. Also, having an all you can eat salad bar was a bonus. The homemade desserts are wonderful and reasonably priced.
It was like stepping back into the 1970s but I can attest that my meal was delicious. I had the Seafood Norfolk, a shrimp and scallop dish in garlic butter and it was succulent and cooked to perfection. The meal came a trip to the...More
The food and service were outstanding. The owner took special interest in making sure we were well taken care of. Excellent seafood at an "inland" restaurant.