Pagliai's is still the best thin crust pizza ever. I been eating there since 1977. It's all about fresh ingredients and the sauce spices.
1 - 10 of 263 reviews
I have to tell you. I scratch my head when people tell me about Pagliai's. And I do this head scratching frequently because so many people tell me that the had dinner here last night and that it is the best pizza in the world....More
Pagliai's is OK pizza. Not bad, not great. Price is really high compared to any other pizza in Iowa City. There are many other pizza places in Iowa City that have better pizza, and are not as expensive as Pagliai's. I don't understand the hype...More
I hadn't been to Pagliai's for a while just because of crazy schedule, etc. My mother-in-law treated myself and my wife there for dinner on a Sunday evening and it's such GREAT pizza. From the cashier, to pizza makers to wait staff, they are non...More
Since the mid 70’s this place has been my very favorite for real Italian Pizza. A&A Pagliai makes their own special sauce which is a family secret😊 My son worked here in high school and said the kitchen is kept immaculate and all the ingredients...More