Pizza was disgusting, I really expected better with all the great reviews but was very disappointed when I went here. NOT WORTH YOUR MONEY.
1 - 10 of 154 reviews
There for a party. Place very loud. Good for younger crowd, not so much for families with kids or for older couples. Pizzas were decent, but Italian Stallion Sandwich was bleh. Service was slow and frustrating. Will not go back.
One of the best atmospheres I've ever experienced as far as a pizza joint,, Friendly servers and fast service.. Pizza had great taste but was cold.. Definitely gonna visit again hopefully it was a one time thing...
This is a convenient stop if you're downtown at lunchtime. Huge slices and always a good selection of choices. The lunch special with either a salad or breadstick along with a drink is a great deal. While there isn't much seating, the Cheapside pavilion is...More
Thank you for your awesome review Billie! We are so glad you enjoyed the lunch special, you might enjoy our 1/2 off 12" Monday special! We hope to see you there!
Stopped in for a quick slice while in the area on business. When I got out to my rental car and took a bite, it was lukewarm and had the consistency of cardboard. Pretty disappointing after hearing the good reviews.
They make a solid slice of pizza at a great location in Lexington's distillery district. It's also a prohibition style bar with a great bourbon selection and good cocktails.
This is the second location is Lexington and it is a treasure! Located in a refurbished bourbon distillery it has tons of atmosphere and history. Make sure and check out the chimney stack room, great photo of. They serve pizza by the slice or whole...More
This place has no business calling themselves good fellas.. The pizza is terrible and the staff are complete jerks. Unbelievably bad customer service...
We went to the one at the distillery district. The food was outstanding and the atmosphere is fun. Loved the pizza!
Thank you for your kind compliments!
Goodfellas Pizzeria is in an area of industrial buildings that are being revitalized with drinking and dining occupancies. A lot going on in this area so the entire area was busy with locals; the initial downer was finding parking. Goodfellas has a variety of sizes,...More
We appreciate your feedback Sheldon! We are hopeful that the parking situation will get better as the city continues to build up the Distillery District area. We are sorry to hear that the seating situation was complicated but glad you came out to give us...More