The bar was nice. The staff was really nice. But the food...not really much flavor there. We got the lobster pasta and had to drench it in pepper, cheese, and salt before it was semi edible.
1 - 10 of 298 reviews
This spring on two different trips to Edgartown I had dinner with friends at Alchemy. Their menu is quite inventive, presentation beautiful and service impeccable. One evening we sat at the bar and had drinks and light food and opit was as enjoyable as having...More
Had a great meal at Alchemy. Pork belly starter, pork tenderloin and fresh fish for the mains. The smoked ocean broth on the halibut was very intriguing and delicious. Megan the wine director was very helpful in choosing a unique white for us to try....More
Went with a group of girlfriends. Atmosphere was quaint, nice outside deck upstairs and overall the food was tasty and nice wine selection.
I have been going to alchemy since before it was alchemy and have never had a bad meal(see earlier review) . However that's not true any longer. Had dinner there recently and it was quite awful. Ordered the halibut which I love. When it was...More
Our favorite restaurant in town with a French Bistro atmosphere. The staff was more professional than friendly. The hummus plate as starter is delicious. The fish was fresh and tasty.
They would have got five stars from me but for a couple things - we asked to split a salad and if the kitchen would split into two plates. Waitress insistent there was a policy against it. At least she brought two spoons & two...More